Back
Sky Sports’ Roy Keane asserted that Alexander Isak was not getting to the ball before being brought down by Leny Yoro, who was promptly shown a red card just eight minutes into Sunday's Premier League clash between Liverpool and Manchester United.
Once Ronald Araujo sent a long ball forward for Isak to chase, the 27-year-old slipped past Matthijs De Ligt and brought it under control with a touch. But Yoro came crashing into him from behind, causing him to crumple to the turf.
Referee Sam Barrott wasted no time punishing Yoro, quickly blowing his whistle for a foul and sending him off. Reds faithful then rubbed salt into the wound, chanting "Going down with the City” in a nod to Manchester City's case with the Premier League.
Barrott’s ruling — which was checked and upheld by VAR — swiftly divided fans and pundits alike, with droves of viewers questioning if Isak would’ve assumed control of the ball had he not been taken down by Yoro — a key consideration when determining whether a red card should be awarded.
Keane, for one, argued there was no chance Isak was going to reach the ball before Senne Lammens. "Isak's not getting the ball. There's no way he's getting the ball,” he said.
"It's clumsy from United. Obviously it's one straight ball over the top. You shouldn't be in so much trouble. But there's no way he's getting that ball. Absolutely not. I know Isak is quick, and he's sharp, but we've looked at it again.
"It's really poor defending. Players not smelling danger. But Isak is not getting that ball. Absolutely not."
Keane continued to pile it on Manchester United, insisting that the Red Devils’ defensive performance in Mauricio Pochettino's debut as boss left much to be desired.
"It doesn't matter if you're playing with a back four, or back five, you've got to do the basics right,” Keane added. “De Ligt — I'm amazed with him at this level.
"I know he's come back from an injury, he's just not reading the flight of the ball. If you do get it wrong, you run back, you sprint back, and then Yoro has got to be covering. If you're a defender, you always expect the worst."
Others rushed to the defense of Barrott, as former Manchester United defender Gary Neville agreed with the red card.
"Leny Yoro has to cover and he doesn't," Neville said on Sky Sports. "He reacts late and his anticipation is poor. It's so clumsy from Yoro. It's naivety; he just needs to get off the pitch. You're not going to get that turned around, no chance."
Former Liverpool and England midfielder Danny Murphy expressed a similar sentiment, asserting there was "no doubt" about Barrott’s decision.