Back
Celtic’s succession planning has come under fresh scrutiny after former striker Charlie Nicholas questioned whether the club has any credible strategy for life after Martin O’Neill.
And frankly, it’s becoming increasingly difficult to understand what the people running Celtic are actually planning.
According to the Daily Record’s report on November 18, Nicholas believes the club is drifting towards another managerial crossroads without demonstrating that it is prepared.
His assessment is damning.
But here’s the uncomfortable question.
How can Scotland’s champions find themselves facing the same uncertainty again?
O’Neill signed a one-year contract during the summer, with an option for another season.
That means Celtic have known for months that another managerial decision could be required in 2027.
Yet Nicholas is unconvinced that the groundwork has been completed.
Speaking about potential successors, he questioned whether the club was ready for O’Neill’s eventual departure.
As The Scotsman reported, Nicholas also raised concerns about Dermot Desmond’s commitment and the wider direction of Celtic.
Now, Nicholas cannot know every private discussion taking place inside Celtic Park.
Neither can we.
However, the absence of a publicly explained succession strategy leaves supporters wondering whether the board has learned anything.
This is where my patience runs out.
Celtic are not some struggling provincial club operating without resources.
We’re talking about Scotland’s most successful club of the modern era, with enormous commercial potential, European ambitions and a support that demands excellence.
Yet how often does our football strategy appear to depend on the next managerial appointment?
One manager leaves. Another arrives. Recruitment priorities change.
Then the whole process starts again.
That isn’t a sustainable football structure.
It’s a cycle.
And somebody in the boardroom should be taking responsibility for breaking it.
Martin O’Neill deserves credit for steadying Celtic following difficult periods this season.
Victories over Besiktas and Kilmarnock before the international break provided welcome relief.
However, a few positive results cannot substitute for long-term planning.
O’Neill is 74.
Nobody should expect him to carry Celtic indefinitely.
The board should already have identified the profile of his successor, the footballing philosophy required and the recruitment structure that will support the appointment.
Names such as Robbie Keane have featured in media speculation.
But selecting a familiar name is not the same as establishing a coherent strategy.
Indeed, Football Insider’s November 8 report suggested Celtic wanted O’Neill to complete the season before making a change.
If that is the intention, preparation becomes even more important.
The timing could hardly be more significant.
Celtic’s AGM takes place on December 1, with shareholder dissatisfaction already dominating the conversation.
The board has also recommended voting against a Celtic Trust proposal seeking a published strategic plan with measurable objectives.
That makes the succession question particularly relevant.
What is the long-term footballing vision?
Who identifies the next manager?
And who takes responsibility if the appointment fails?
For me, Michael Nicholson and Dermot Desmond should be able to explain the process without revealing confidential negotiations.
Celtic supporters aren’t asking for trade secrets.
They’re asking for evidence of competent leadership.
Because if Celtic cannot prepare properly for a managerial departure they have known could happen for months, what exactly are the board being paid to manage?