Back
Liverpool and the 18 other Premier League clubs will be asked to provide legal cover for the division's five board directors in the event of a Manchester City sponsor deciding to sue them, according to reports, amid an ongoing battle between the club and league.
It comes as part of a clash between the two parties which has spanned years, beginning in 2018 when the Premier League decided to investigate Manchester City after the Football Leaks saga, which saw hacker Rui Pinto gain access to emails from several teams that had private information which pointed towards potential misconduct.
That investigation lasted roughly five years, culminating in the club being charged with 115 allegations of breaching the rules. That included suggestions that sponsorship deals and contracts had been misrepresented to inflate revenues and reduce costs, which would then help towards compliance with financial rules spanning from 2009 until 2018, as well as non-compliance in the investigation period.
A hearing from an independent panel took place over several weeks, but the final verdict wouldn't drop until late September this year, when it was announced that Man City was found guilty on 114 charges.
A statement from the Premier League made reference to "sham contracts" that helped inflate revenues by well over $1 billion, which caused subsequent historical financial breaches.
Man City denies any wrongdoing and has since submitted an appeal. The outcome of that, which is not re-litigation but rather a questioning of the decision process, is set to be revealed in the coming months if the timelines suggested by the rules are followed.
One thing this legal battle has revealed is that these things are bigger than soccer now. Whether it's the potential geopolitical aspect of any sanctions or even the lawfare involved in such deals, this is more than just being 22 people on a field kicking a ball around.
That much is evident when threats of potential legal action from sponsors have been floated. Etihad Airways, the sponsor of the first-team shirts and stadium naming rights, suggested that legal action may be taken for suggestions that it was “involved in improper commercial arrangements”.
Etihad, which is owned by the Abu-Dhabi government, claimed that damages for implications of wrongdoing could be part of a case. Etisalat, the telecommunications company, also warned of legal action for "entirely false and defamatory" publication of the allegations from the Premier League.
With that in mind, The Times reports that under current legislation, the Premier League's board of directors are not currently protected by the possibility of legal action from third parties.
Richard Masters, Alison Brittain, Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder KC are the five who would be impacted by such a challenge from outside of the Premier League, with fear that any push towards lawfare from elsewhere could result in hundreds of millions of dollars in fees.
A planned meeting among Premier League clubs will take place later this week, in which they will be asked to change the rules that provide legal protection, which would leave the teams, including Liverpool, having to cover the legal expenses and any potential damages awarded.
It remains to be seen whether they will vote favor of an amendment, and whether there is an appetite to help fund the latest twist that seems to be unravelling in this pandora's box of a case.