flag
back Back
'One of the Best' Managers is New Favourite for Man Utd Job, He's a Nagelsmann Upgrade

Oct 23, 2026, 6:15 PM GMT+1

James Beavis is a Senior Editor at GIVEMESPORT and has worked in the online football media industry for more than 10 years, having graduated with a Sports Journalism degree from Southampton Solent University in 2012.

James joined Football FanCast in 2016 following a three-year spell working for Shoot Magazine, working his way up from freelance writer to editor, before moving across to GMS in 2020.

James has created exclusive, opinion and news content on GIVEMESPORT, with a predominant focus on the Premier League.

He has also developed strong working relationships with top tier journalists such as Fabrizio Romano, Dharmesh Sheth and Ben Jacobs, regularly chatting to them as part of an exclusives initiative.

Sign in to your GiveMeSport account

Manchester United manager Michael Carrick is set to take charge of the Premier League clash against Bournemouth at Old Trafford on Sunday, but club chiefs are considering their options if they do need to make a change.

Man United are seven matches without a win following Wednesday night's 4-1 thrashing at Como, with Carrick winning just two of his 11 games in charge this term.

The Red Devils look a completely different team to the one that soared to a third-place finish in the Premier League last term, under the interim leadership of Carrick.

The 45-year-old will be under no illusions that he needs a positive result against the Cherries, who will come into the clash at the Theatre of Dreams on a high after they beat AC Milan 3-0 in the Europa League on Thursday night.

Carrick is still trying to find his best XI following the club's summer business and with the players he currently has available to him, with Benjamin Sesko's absence proving to be a big problem.

Bruno Fernandes has even played as a striker at times in recent matches, although Carrick has a decision to make on whether he starts the Portugal international against Bournemouth after he publicly criticised his manager's tactics after the Como defeat.

Carrick's Record in 2026-27 Season

Games

11

Wins

2

Draws

4

Losses

5

Win percentage

18.18%

The former Middlesbrough boss is still working out how to effectively use Youri Tielemans, Carlos Baleba, Andrey Santos, Kobbie Mainoo and Fernandes in a starting line-up, while the lack of quality in depth in defence is a concern too.

A whole host of managers are being linked with the potential managerial vacancy already, with GIVEMESPORT senior correspondent Ben Jacobs revealing that Brighton and Hove Albion coach Fabian Hurzeler and former Germany manager Julian Nagelsmann are among the names admired by the hierarchy, although the former has no interest in leaving the Seagulls mid-season.

According to talkSPORT, Eddie Howe is emerging as the new favourite for the job if Carrick leaves, having departed Newcastle United after nearly five years in charge during the summer.

Howe Would be Much Better Than Nagelsmann

Eddie Howe

The same report claims that head of recruitment Christopher Vivell views Nagelsmann as the standout candidate if a change is made, but Wilcox prefers Howe and his opinion is likely to carry more weight with Sir Jim Ratcliffe and the Glazers.

It is an interesting decision between the two as they clearly both have their strengths and weaknesses, but Howe would be the better fit for United right now.

  • November 2021 — Howe appointed Newcastle head coach, replacing Steve Bruce after the Saudi-backed takeover.
  • February 2023 — Howe reached Newcastle's first final in 24 years, losing 2-0 to Manchester United.
  • May 2023 — Newcastle finished fourth, returning to the Champions League after two decades away.
  • March 2025 — Newcastle beat Liverpool 2-1 at Wembley, ending a 70-year trophy wait.
  • July 2025 — Howe steps down as Newcastle manager.

Howe was appointed as manager of Newcastle in November 2021 and, at the time, it was a club divided from top to bottom because of the previous regimes of Mike Ashley and Steve Bruce.

Howe quickly galvanised the whole club and, 18 months later, they had gone from Premier League relegation battlers to qualifying for the Champions League, aided of course by the Saudi investment.

The 48-year-old got everyone pulling in the same direction at St James' Park and the atmosphere on home matchdays was completely transformed, and the dressing room was more tight-knit than it had been for years.

Premier League Era Before or After

Did it happen before or after?

Round 1 of 9

Howe is clearly a good man-manager and tactically he impressed during his time as Newcastle manager, as they went toe-to-toe with the likes of Barcelona and Paris Saint-Germain in the Champions League.

Some United fans may not think he is the glamorous appointment they need after Carrick, but he would get the team organised and everyone pulling in the same direction, and that could be priceless for a club in crisis.

You may like

Erling Haaland: Barcelona, Real Madrid react to Man City star setting ‘one key condition’ to acce...

football365.com 6 hours ago

Arsenal transfer news: Gunners plotting to 'steal' Bayern Munich prospect

sportsmole.co.uk 4 hours ago

Man Utd boss Carrick told to make brutal decision on ‘disgraceful’ Fernandes in ‘last’ act before...

football365.com 1 hour ago

Man Utd manager candidates highlight outside view of club as dressing room chaos raised

Mirror 1 hour ago

Kyle Walker Now Issues Statement Addressing His Man City Tattoo Removal Comments

givemesport.com 58 minutes ago

Premier League star refuses to take the knee AGAIN: Ipswich defender Issa Diop rejects anti-racis...

Daily Mail 41 minutes ago

Man Utd boss's brilliant five minute speech sent a brutal message to his players

Express 4 hours ago

Jaap Stam picks who is better between Martin Odegaard and Chelsea’s Cole Palmer

arsenalinsider.com 1 hour ago

Former Tottenham Star Knocks Out Ex-Arsenal Ace as Footage From Boxing Match Emerges

givemesport.com 6 hours ago

Ruud van Nistelrooy releases official statement addressing managerial claims

centredevils.co.uk 2 hours ago