Back
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS - AUGUST 24: Jake Burger #21 of the Texas Rangers smiles in the dugout after hitting a solo home run in the fifth inning against the Chicago White Sox at Rate Field on August 24, 2026 in Chicago, Illinois. (Photo by Zoe Davis/Getty Images)
Getty ImagesThe Cleveland Guardians have a top prospect waiting in the wings to claim the role as the team’s every day first baseman.
If things go according to plan, left-handed hitting Ralphy Velazquez, 21, could be promoted to the parent Guardians at some point in the 2027 Major League Baseball season.
Velazquez is ranked the No. 1 prospect in the Guardians farm system by mlb.com.
mlb.com also ranks Velazquez the top overall prospect first baseman in Major League Baseball, and the No. 29 overall player among all prospect position players and pitchers.
By all accounts, Ralphy Velazquez could be a star. However, he must first finish his development at Triple-A Columbus.
A look at the Guardians 40-man roster following the addition of three players November 17 reveals a need for offensive help at first base.
The roster currently includes three players with major league, first base experience. They include:
Kyle Manzardo-Age 26-Bats Left
CJ Kayfus-Age 25-Bats Left
David Fry-Age 30-Bats Right
New to the 40-man roster, Kody Huff is a right-handed hitting catcher, who might also be able to play first base. But he is a catcher, first and foremost.
Ultimately, I see him in the David Fry role.
Velazquez did not have to be protected on the 40-man roster yet. However, he will be added to the 40-man when he graduates to the big leagues.
Of the group above, Manzardo has played 297 career games in the big leagues. All with Cleveland.
Manzardo has a .228 career batting average, with 45 homers, and 124 RBIs in 1,043 plate appearances. He has struck out 290 times.
His complete MLB line is: .228/.306/.424/.730 in 297 games played.
According to baseballreference.com Manzardo finished his 2026 season at Triple-A Columbus. He played 37 games, and hit .283/.352/.469/.820, with five homers and 35 RBIs in 165 plate appearances.
Frankly, I don’t think Manzardo and his inconsistency in the big leagues represents the answer at first base for Cleveland.
Texas Rangers first baseman Jake Burger, 30, is 6-0, 230 pounds.
He’s a strong guy.
Jake Burger hits right handed.
Jake Burger is a first baseman.
Jake Burger is a power hitter.
Jake Burger is arbitration eligible with the Texas Rangers
Jake Burger meets a great number of the Guardians needs in a first baseman.
Having completed six seasons in MLB, Burger was a first round, 2017 selection of the Chicago White Sox.
Burger played for the White Sox, the Miami Marlins, and the Rangers.
baseballreference.com noted Burger is coming off a 2026 season where he hit .228/.302/.421/.732, with 28 homers, and 90 RBIs.
He struck out 167 times, in 620 plate appearances.
While his batting average, and high strikeout rates may remind some of Manzardo, he has more consistent power, hits right-handed, and is a more feared hitter than Manzardo.
Burger is estimated to be worth a $6.9 Million contract in MLB salary arbitration.
The Guardians would have to trade for him, if they want Burger as their first baseman.
If the Guardians traded for Burger, they would control his contract until after the 2028 season, when he could become a free agent.
Yahoosports believes the Guardians already have an additional $46.7 Million in estimated contract obligations for their current 12 arbitration eligible players.
justbaseball.com believes the figure to be $47,437,500.
Usatoday listed the Guardians 2026 opening day payroll to have been around $74.2 Million. They ranked 30th in Major League Baseball.
Assuming they added $7 Million for Burger, and $48 Million for the current Guardians arbitration class, they would have a payroll in the area of $130 Million, which quite frankly, is probably still low compared to most major league club’s payroll floors.
One must remember that David Blitzer, a New Jersey based Guardians minority (and other sports teams) investor, has a path to ownership of the Guardians.
Blitzer may have to sign off on all Guardians payroll moves.
But for this old scout, right-handed first baseman Jake Burger should be a trade target for Cleveland.
The Cleveland Guardians need a right-handed, power hitting first baseman, and Jake Burger checks those boxes.