flag
back Back
The case to play no specialist spinner in the Gqeberha Port Elizabeth Test
News: According to reports, 6-8mm of grass will be on the Gqeberha pitch, so is there a case for no specialist spinner?

Last Updated on 13 seconds ago by Charbel Coorey

According to reports, St. George’s Park head groundsman Adrian Carter is set to leave 6-8mm of grass on the pitch for the second Test. On a ground where spin often plays a role, there may be limited opportunities for the likes of Nathan Lyon and Keshav Maharaj to get into the game.

Along with pitch, there is rain forecast on the first two days. The weather is expected to be fine for the final three days, but mild conditions – with top temperatures in the low 20s – means the surface is unlikely to break up at the backend of the match.

Should South Africa and Australia go without a specialist spinner in Gqeberha?

In theory, playing a Test in Gqeberha without a specialist spinner is a risk. Spinners make up four of the top 10 wicket-takers on this ground in the last decade, with Maharaj top of the list with 33 wickets at 23.88.

In fact, offspinners (a tick under 26) and left-arm orthodox (a tick under 27) have the best bowling averages of any bowling type at St George’s Park since 2016.

David Bedingham says the pitch has been tricky to bat on in recent years, with conditions favouring spin.

“Personally, I haven’t played too much (here), but from speaking to everyone, it’s usually quite slow and low,” Bedingham said, as quoted by CODE Sports.

“But also in first-class cricket, I reckon for the last three or four years, it’s been the toughest place to play. So I don’t know what the pitch guy (groundsman) will do… but hopefully it’s a good pitch, and hopefully there’s a Proteas win on hopefully day four or five.”

So both camps have tricky decisions to make. The Port Elizabeth surface usually dries out as the match goes on, but will the weather conditions allow for that? Also, despite the grass, will the pitch still play on the slower side as it usually does?

Australia have the excellent Scott Boland waiting in the wings, who would relish an opportunity to bowl on a grassy pitch even if it’s not as pacy as other grounds. The only avenue into the XI, if every bowler is fit, is in place of Lyon.

South Africa also have options, namely Dane Paterson, Corbin Bosch and Gerald Coetzee. Paterson has had success on this ground, taking eight wickets in two Tests at an average of 20.75.

Pace bowlers had the better of proceedings at Durban on a pitch that had less grass. Also, conditions were warm and sunny throughout the Test, but the quicks – especially Josh Hazlewood – were still able to have the most success.

There is the option of playing a spinner in case the surface offers assistance late in the Test. Both Lyon and Maharaj are skilled, experience and can make use of whatever help there is. It will be fascinating to see which way both teams go.

You may like

South Africa possible 11 for 2nd Test against Australia at Gqeberha Port Elizabeth

cricblog.net 1 day ago

Aiden Markram fitness update: South Africa star misses training ahead of 2nd Test vs Australia

cricketaddictor.com 11 hours ago

Kagiso Rabada, Anrich Nortje fully fit and available for 2nd Test vs Australia

cricketaddictor.com 7 hours ago

Proteas get Rabada boost but batting again in the spotlight

timeslive.co.za 3 hours ago

Rabada boost for under pressure South Africa

cricbuzz.com 3 hours ago

SA vs AUS Playing 11 Today, Live Streaming, Pitch & Weather: South Africa vs Australia 2nd Test 2026

cricketaddictor.com 7 hours ago

South Africa look to re-establish test credentials after Australia mauling

straitstimes.com 1 day ago

Rabada returns as Proteas rejig for Gqeberha Test

sacricketmag.com 3 hours ago

Hazlewood says reverse swing may be a factor in South Africa test series

straitstimes.com 1 day ago

South Africa still mulling over permutations for second test against Australia

straitstimes.com 6 hours ago