Back
We’re now 10 matches into the Premier League season, and it feels like we’ve now got enough data to start judging both players and teams fairly – and as we’ve also got some time on our hands during the international break, we’re going to do just that and judge the 10 best new signings of the 2026/27 season so far.
We’ve decided to rank players based purely on their performances for their new club rather than taking the size of the transfer fee into account, which made sense given that none of the players we felt had been among the best new arrivals were all that cheap anyway. The fees listed below are the reported maximum amounts including add-ons.
The order is obviously somewhat arbitrary – exactly how are you meant to judge a goalkeeper against a striker anyway? – but we reckon it provides a pretty fair representation of how well some of the fresh faces are settling in. Let’s crack on…
Aston Villa had a very tough assignment this summer – to replace Ollie Watkins, Morgan Rogers and Emi Martínez, arguably their three most important players, on a relatively limited budget. They smashed it, as the first half of our Top 10 will attest. Suzuki has provided an immense physical presence in the penalty area, but it’s his shot stopping which has stood out more than his capacity to claim high balls. The Japan international has a 72% save percentage and has prevented 2.4 goals according to the xG model. Both are very impressive numbers indeed.
Some will argue that signing Van Hecke was a mistake given that his arrival compelled the departure of Luka Vušković – more on him later, as you might have guessed – but Roberto De Zerbi’s decision to pick up a player he knew and trusted makes plenty of sense given how well he’s played. The lanky Dutchman has been Spurs’ best player by a distance this season, outstanding both in the air and on the ground, on and off the ball. He’s a defender with no meaningful weaknesses. Heaven knows where Spurs would have ended up without him already.
The 21-year-old burst into the global footballing consciousness with a brilliant performance for Switzerland at the World Cup and has made a superb start to life in Birmingham as the replacement for Rogers – he’s scored three goals and created three more in his first 10 appearances and his boundless energy has had a transformative impact on his side. Before Manzambi made his delayed debut, Aston Villa were struggling. Since he got back to full fitness, they’ve been winning games again, and there’s a growing correlation between Manzambi’s form and Villa’s as a whole.
Earlier this season, we published a column wondering whether Jacquet would prove to be the single best signing of the summer. He’s had a couple of iffy outings since then – he struggled up against Romelu Lukaku in the Champions League recently, for instance – but the towering Frenchman has been outstanding more often than not. He’s dominant in one-on-one situations, a colossal presence in the air, and his surging runs and precise passing have offered Liverpool an excellent base for possession. He’s only 21, as well, so we can reasonably expect plenty more to come as he matures.
We had a tough time deciding whether Manzambi or Jackson could claim more responsibility for Villa’s turnaround, but it’s the Senegalese striker who’s been scoring the goals – nine already in 14 appearances in all competitions. He wasn’t cheap given public perceptions of his form over the past few years, but Villa did well to look past the frustrating misses to see a forward who has always scored at a healthy rate and whose pace and guileful movements can give high lines a major headache.
Briefly the most expensive Englishman in the history of the game, the only problem that Anderson’s arrival at the Etihad has created is that Manchester City already rely on him a little bit too much. That’s understandable, however, given that Anderson is undoubtedly one of the best defensive midfielders in the world right now, something the stats have attested to since the switch. He’s probably been the only City player to consistently play well this season, even through their recent wobble.
The Bosnian centre-back was excellent in Serie A last season and most of Italy’s biggest sides were linked with a bid. It would appear that they messed up by letting him head to Elland Road instead. Muharemović has been among the best defenders in the top flight but it’s preternatural positional sense that really stands out – he’s in the right spot so often that it almost feel freakish, and the result has been an enormous average of 8.5 clearances per match. He’s damned good in one-on-one situations, too. An excellent acquisition.
If Trafford’s aim was to prove that Manchester City shouldn’t have allowed him to rot on the bench, then he’s done a very good job of it indeed. The numbers behind the 24-year-old’s work are astonishing – his 82% save percentage leads the entire league and the statisticians credit him with saving 4.36 goals’ worth of post-shot xG. For anyone who isn’t a stats nerd, that’s a perfectly respectable total for an entire season. After 10 games? It’s utterly ridiculous. The four clean sheets he’s kept don’t do him (or Muharemović) justice.
The fact that Chelsea are in the top four conversation is a testament to both a degree of luck – as we recently noted, Xabi Alonso’s side haven’t been playing as well as results suggest – and to the firepower of João Pedro and Morgan Rogers, who are dragging a mediocre team up towards relevance. Rogers’ superb solo goal against Manchester United was perhaps the best example of his capacity to win matches by himself, but he’s already got 10 combined goals and assists to his name and is both scoring and creating at the fastest rate of his career. He’s the most expensive Englishman of all time, but he’s also playing like it.
Maybe Spurs didn’t see it coming, but given how good Vušković was on loan at Hamburg last season, it’s not exactly a surprise to see him flourish with the Seagulls. Brighton have kept a clean sheet in seven of their nine games since the last international break and the Croatian is the key differential between the rock steady defence we’re now seeing in Sussex and the less reliable unit that they had last season. He’s been brilliant in the air, his positioning has been exceptional and he’s been forcing turnovers at a rate that puts most other centre-backs in the shade. He’s pretty confident in possession, too, and recently took top spot in our weekly Wonderkid Power Rankings. Oh, and he’s 19 years old. God knows how good he’ll be in five years’ time – and god knows how long Brighton will be able to keep hold of him.