Back
Ex-Springboks boss Nick Mallett sympathises with Rassie Erasmus but doesn’t know how he can defend his comments that led to a six-match ban.
SA Rugby quickly confirmed that they had requested a full misconduct hearing after World Rugby handed down its sanction, with Erasmus punished for his comments around the officiating of his team’s clash with France in the Nations Championship.
The current head coach complained about the number of knee-drop tackles by Les Bleus that went unpunished and questioned whether the lack of punishment equated to ‘match-fixing’ if the referee and TMO are choosing not to penalise.
Erasmus claimed that there were 16/17 of those incidents that were missed with his officiating rant resulting in swift action from the game’s governing body. Commenting on the former Springboks flanker’s remarks, Mallett said that he should never have suggested that match-fixing and should have aired his dismay with the refereeing through the right channels.
“As an ex-coach, I completely and utterly sympathise with the frustration that he must have in numerous areas of the game,” Mallett said on the Talking Boks podcast.
“First of all, the game is so complex that the referees are going to miss certain things. What you want is a balance; if the ref misses certain things on your side, you want to make sure that they are also missing certain things on the other side.
“Every coach has to understand that there are going to be these anomalies in a game where you don’t believe that the ref got it right, but as long as you feel that he’s doing it fairly, we can live with it.”
Mallett believes that Erasmus made a crucial mistake when airing his complaints to the media on Monday in that he went a step too far, which landed him in hot water.
“Now, what actually happened on this, I think it was a media thing that developed, and Rassie was saying, ‘There were 16 or 17 knee-drop tackles that were missed,’ and one could have left it there.
“One could have then said: ‘This is disappointing, and I think World Rugby needs to have a look at this. Clearly, this is an area which referees and TMOs haven’t got hold of properly because it is a safety issue and, I’m only allowed to send five clips, et cetera, and so let’s hope that World Rugby can sort this out with the refereeing community’.
“But when you add on to that, now is missing a certain number of knee-drop tackles, is that influencing the game or could that be construed as match-fixing? I think as soon as you go down that road, you are in very, very dangerous territory because the inference is maybe that’s what happened against France. You’re not saying it, but by talking about it as being that – by missing it in inverted commas – perhaps it was deliberately missed.”
He believes Erasmus is going to have a hard time expunging the ban because of those remarks, as World Rugby will be keen to make an example of him again as they look to protect the officials.
“Now, I don’t think you as a coach should ever say something like that about the officials. You have to go through the proper channels, proper channels that are being given to you by, and that you signed up for as a coach,” he continued.
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
“I think that the speed with which they banned him for six games and also the speed with which we are now obviously going to have a full misconduct inquiry is not a bad thing in a sense that World Rugby is protecting its officials, and Rassie is saying: ‘No, that’s not what I meant at all’, I don’t know how he’s going to defend himself.
“What I’m saying is that World Rugby has to protect the officials. They have to make sure that those officials aren’t called out in the media for any sort of semblance of cheating or trying to influence a game or any of that – that would completely break down the trust between players, fans, coaches, and people who love the game.”
Mallett concluded by questioning what the Boks benefit from the suspension of their head coach.
“So what I’m concerned with is that Rassie is a very intelligent guy, and why would he have done it? By saying those things, he would have known that there would be a massive reaction to his words, and he is bright enough to realise that there was a very strong likelihood that he would be banned,” he said.
“So where’s the upside for South Africa on this? Where do we benefit from him not being there now? And where do we benefit in the long-term, making everyone p***ed off with us? I can’t see the upside to this.”