Back
Matt is an experienced sports journalist and Senior Editor at Football FanCast with 15 years of experience covering football across the Premier League, EFL and Scottish football. Since joining the publication in 2019, he has progressed from writer to Assistant Editor and Senior Editor, a position he has held since 2021.
A Sports Journalism graduate, Matt previously served as Arsenal and Premier League Editor at VAVEL and gained club-media experience with Chesterfield FC. His journalism has appeared through the Press Association, with his work featured by Sky Sports and the Daily Mail.
Throughout his career, Matt has interviewed prominent football figures including Arsène Wenger, Ray Parlour, Alan Smith, Lucy Bronze and Steph Houghton, while also appearing on Arsenal Fan TV and Love Sport Radio.
Today, Matt leads Football FanCast's features team, overseeing opinion coverage, editorial standards and content strategy while continuing to provide detailed football analysis.
Bruno Guimaraes was never going to receive a raucous applause on his return to St James' Park. The Arsenal midfielder forced an exit over the summer and isn't exactly the flavour of the month at Newcastle United.
He was booed upon entry to his former home and was jeered right throughout his time on the pitch. It was hardly a surprise.
What has been surprising, however, are the performances of the Brazilian since making that mega £75m switch back in August.
Guimaraes was once again underwhelming on Saturday evening, even if the boss was pleased with his display.
After trading the north east for north London, Bruno has had his moments.
There was that magical long-range effort against Sunderland. He really enjoyed that one. There was also the spellbinding winner against Leeds United when he combined quickly with Declan Rice.
Those moments aside, however, Guimaraes has struggled to get up to speed. The simple fact is that when the 29-year-old starts, Arteta's team are poorer for it.
Indeed, the Gunners have either been behind or level in four of the midfielder's eight starts at the club. Worringly for him, Arsenal have gone on to better the result in 75% of the games after he went off.
This wasn't in the script. Arteta had brought in a proven Premier League player, one of the best midfielders in the top flight. So far, he has not shown that.
The manager said his display back at St James' was "very good" but we beg to differ. Hauled off after 70 minutes, he did so having missed a big chance. He failed to complete either of his two dribbles, won just three of his seven duels and had 35 touches, seven fewer than David Raya who left the field at the same moment with an injury.
| Guimaraes vs Newcastle |
|
|---|---|
| Minutes played |
70 |
| Touches |
35 |
| Shots |
1 |
| Shots on target |
0 |
| Chances created |
0 |
| Defensive contributions |
5 |
| Tackles |
1 |
| Successful dribbles |
0/2 |
| Accurate passes |
21/24 (88%) |
| Ball recoveries |
2 |
| Duels won |
3/7 |
Despite sitting pretty at the top of the table, Arsenal's summer recruitment is being called into question. Alongside Guimaraes, Christos Tzolis is also struggling. The Greek was vibrant in the opening exchanges of his career at the Emirates but we're now approaching December and he is still yet to score a single goal.
The strange thing about this season is that there are plenty of faces in Arteta's squad who are actually underperforming right now.
Last season, Arsenal's squad depth was lauded as the best in Europe. It was one of the biggest reasons for their Premier League title success and it played a large part in why they reached the Champions League final too.
Yet, this term, while it is still impressive, there are now holes appearing. Neither Viktor Gyokeres or Kai Havertz look good enough to lead the line. On the flanks, Gabriel Martinelli and Leandro Trossard were both let go with only Tzolis arriving. Now, with Saka out too, it feels like they lack genuine quality.
On paper, their depth in midfield also looks strong but Declan Rice and Myles Lewis-Skelly aside, we have seen some rather average performances.
Guimaraes is still getting used to Arteta's style of play, Martin Zubimendi has been linked with a move away and Mikel Merino has gone from being Mr Clutch to being Mr Redundant.
Both have enjoyed a fabulous 2026 on a personal level, not just winning the English top-flight but also returning to London Colney after the summer having won the World Cup. Yet, neither have kicked on since, particularly Merino.
The Spaniard has been a mighty fine signing at just £31m. Whether it be as an emergency striker or as a super sub, the 30-year-old has far exceeded all expectations.
As a centre-forward, he has scored ten goals and supplied six assists in 23 matches. In midfield, however, where he has been deployed this term, he has never looked like the same player, netting six times in 59 appearances.
While a midfielder's primary duty is not to contribute in the final third, Merino has struggled, particularly this season, to really come alive. His only assist of the campaign came against Slavia Prague in the Champions League while his only goal was against Ipswich when he actually captained the side in the Carabao Cup.
Now back to full fitness after struggling with injury in 2025/26, it looks as though this could be the beginning of the end for the experienced midfielder at Arsenal. He has started just one Premier League game all term and his performance off the bench against Newcastle on Saturday night showed why he hasn't been trusted as much.
He came on in injury time and had just seven touches of the ball while completing only 67% of his passes. In that moment, Arteta needed clutch Merino, the Merino who scored two vitally important goals off the bench for Spain at the World Cup.
The manager did not get it. Instead, he got a laboured cameo when Arsenal were pushing for goal. Laboured is the definition of what Merino's season has been this season. Perhaps it's time to let him go in 2027.