Back
Certainly men’s tennis has enjoyed a remarkable two decades in terms of the likability of its best players.
From the moment Roger Federer first became world number one in February 2004, every player at the top of the rankings has been lauded. From Federer to Rafa Nadal to Novak Djokovic to Andy Murray, the big four saw tennis enjoy an unprecedented level of popularity of its top players.
Daniil Medvedev also temporarily made it to the top of the rankings and although his popularity failed to come close to that of the big four, Medvedev was very much still viewed in a positive light by most.
This is why the current unease that’s pervading tennis - specifically the unease that’s crept into the sport following the rise of the new men’s number one - is quite so striking.
Alexander Zverev has been the world number one for nearly two weeks now. And he’s the most unpopular, and I’d even go so far as to say disliked, world number one that the sport has ever seen.
His unpopularity is as a result of several things.
The first is, in my view, somewhat unfair. Zverev’s rise to the top of the rankings has coincided with significant injuries to the two players who have occupied the top spot prior to the German taking over; Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner. With this duo both having had lengthy spells off the court this season, the path was somewhat cleared for Zverev to rise to the top. The criticism that he has risen to number one, aided significantly by how little both Sinner and Alcaraz have played this season, is, I feel, unjustified. While there’s little doubt that the absence of Sinner and Alcaraz has made it considerably easier for Zverev to become the top-ranked player, it’s also somewhat unfair to criticise him for taking advantage of the situation. High-level sport is, amongst other things, about staying fit and Zverev cannot be penalised for neither Sinner nor Alcaraz managing that this season. You can only beat who’s in front of you, and Zverev has done that incredibly effectively, with the German having won both the French Open and US Open in 2026, as well as reaching the final of Wimbledon and the semi-finals of the Australian Open. By anyone’s standards, this is an impressive year.
Zverev won the French Open in 2026 before adding the US Open later in the year (Image: Clive Brunskill)
Where Zverev falls down, though, and where he attracts quite so much criticism in tennis terms is his head-to-head with his fellow ten-ten players. The 29-year-old is as sure a bet as you’ll get to beat those ranked outside of the world’s top ten. His win-loss record this year against players outside of the top ten in the rankings is 62-8. But it’s players inside the top ten that the German struggles badly with. Of the twelve matches Zverev has played against top ten players this season, he has won only three. This is, clearly, a disappointing statistic for someone who’s apparently the best in the world.
But nevertheless, Zverev has done enough to top the rankings list and I’m a firm believer that the rankings don’t lie. Clearly, no bad player manages to become number one in the world and Zverev is certainly not a bad player.
Is he better than either Sinner or Alcaraz? When they’re all at their best, I’d take the Italian and the Spaniard over Zverev every single time but if they’re not fit enough to take to the court, that’s not something for Zverev to worry about.
Both Jannik Sinner (r) and Carlos Alcaraz (l) have missed significant portions of the 2026 season through injury (Image: VALERY HACHE/ Getty Images)
Another reason for Zverev’s unpopularity is his overt arrogance and certainly, his aloof personality and clear dislike for the media (meaning he often comes across chippy and uncooperative in interviews) does little to endear him to the watching public. But Zverev is by no stretch, the only athlete to be arrogant and neither is he under any obligation to be chatty and friendly to everyone he comes across.
His on-court behaviour has been far from perfect, either, with multiple incidents of racquet abuse, unsportsmanlike behaviour and bad language having pockmarked Zverev’s career.
Perhaps tennis has been spoiled by having Federer and Nadal at the top for quite so long, with the pair two of the most likeable individuals in global sport never mind just tennis and so it’s not just Zverev who would struggle to live-up to the standards they set.
It’s the final reason for Zverev’s unpopularity that’s quite so troubling, though.
In 2020, Zverev’s ex-girlfriend, Olga Sharypova, accused him of physical violence and controlling behaviour.
The German maintained his innocence and described the allegations as baseless and ultimately, an investigation instigated by the ATP and carried out by third-party investigator found "insufficient evidence to substantiate published allegations of abuse”.
But then in 2023, Zverev was issued with a penalty order and fined 450,000 euros by a German court for bodily harm against another of his ex-girlfriends, Brenda Patea. Zverev, once again, denied the claims and a public trial began. But just a week into the trial, it ended with a settlement between Zverev and Patea having been reached.
These are hugely troubling allegations and while Zverev may not have been found guilty of any criminal acts, it’s hard for most observers, myself included, to not allow these accusations to cloud my judgement of him.
What’s been interesting over the past fortnight is to observe just how annoyed Zverev is by the adverse reaction to his rise to the top of the ranking. While he’s not addressed the negativity directed towards him as a result of the domestic violence accusations, his rebuke of those who claim he’s not a “worthy” world number one was immediate.
Zverev claimed that he’s the only tennis player who has had to “explain why it's okay" for him to be top of the rankings. Firstly, this isn’t true - see Dinara Safina, Marcelo Ríos, Jelena Jankovic, Thomas Muster - and secondly, tough luck, Alex. You’d think that someone who’s quite so tough physically would be slightly tougher in accepting a touch of criticism.
At the dnd of the day, Zverev gets the last laugh as he’s the one topping the world ranking list. But this is a new era for men’s tennis, and it’s one it would rather not be experiencing; an era in which the top player is not enhancing the reputation of the sport.
And so the sooner Sinner and Alcaraz are back fighting for the top spot, the better.