flag
back Back
A token fan on the board won’t fix what is broken at Celtic.

Celtic has "fans on the board" already. Look what good that's done us.

2025 Scottish Premiership Football Rangers v Celtic May 4th
4th May 2025; Ibrox Stadium, Glasgow, Scotland; Scottish Premiership Football, Rangers versus Celtic; Celtic supporters

I have enormous respect for Paul McStay.

He is one of Celtic’s great former captains, a man who understands what this football club means to its supporters and who has every right to express his opinion about its future.

He means well. He deserves the respect of being listened to. However, when it comes to his suggestion that having a fan representative on the Celtic board could be a step towards resolving the current problems between the club and its support, I have to disagree. And I disagree rather strongly.

In fact, I would argue that this is precisely the sort of half-measure that risks distracting us from the real issues at Celtic.

First of all, who exactly would this representative be? How would we choose this individual? Would there be an election? Who would be eligible to stand? Would supporters vote according to their season-ticket status, membership of a supporters’ organisation or simply their allegiance to Celtic?

And, perhaps most importantly, how would we establish that the person elected genuinely represents the interests of the Celtic support as a whole?

These are not insignificant questions.

They are fundamental to the entire proposal.

We are talking about a community that is currently fractured, divided and increasingly distrustful of the people running its football club.

There are different supporter groups, different campaigns, different opinions and different expectations about what needs to happen next. Some want immediate changes at board level, others want structural reform, while some still defend the current leadership.

So, in such circumstances, how exactly would one individual manage to represent everybody? I cannot see it happening.

There is no magic formula that would suddenly make thousands of supporters trust one person simply because that individual had been given a seat at the boardroom table. Whoever was selected would inevitably face criticism from sections of the support. Some would question their credentials, others their loyalties, and others whether they were sufficiently independent of the existing board.

We could spend months arguing about the person rather than addressing the problems that brought us here in the first place.

And that brings me to my second objection.

A fan representative would be expected to sit around the table and discuss what, exactly? The annual budget? Financial planning? Corporate strategy? Football operations? Recruitment? Potential managerial appointments? Long-term infrastructure investment?

Would this individual have the professional qualifications and experience necessary to contribute meaningfully to those discussions?

Being a passionate Celtic supporter is not a professional qualification. Neither is having attended Celtic Park for forty years, having a season ticket or being able to explain exactly what is wrong with the current football department.

These things can make someone an excellent supporter and a valuable voice in the wider Celtic community, but they do not automatically make that person qualified to make key decisions for a multimillion-pound football business.

I would never confuse passion with professional competence. And I certainly would not want Celtic to make that mistake when deciding how the club should be governed.

There is another contradiction here that deserves attention.

Those who defend the existing board frequently remind us that the people sitting around the table are Celtic supporters themselves.

Apparently, we already have fans in the boardroom! Well, if that is the argument, what exactly would adding another supporter achieve?

Would this new individual have more influence than the existing directors? Would they have the power to challenge decisions, demand accountability or insist on changes to the football operation? Or would they simply become another voice in a room where the important decisions are already made?

Worse; would they be a barely tolerated nuisance, someone who was deliberately excluded whilst the real decisions were made away from their interference and prying eyes? Fans are not interested in symbolic representation.

Fans are interested in meaningful change.

Let me make something clear. I do not believe that supporters should be excluded from discussions about the future of Celtic. Quite the opposite.

The support is the lifeblood of this football club, and the board should be listening to its concerns rather than treating criticism as an inconvenience. There must be proper channels of communication, transparency and accountability.

However, there is a considerable difference between giving supporters a meaningful voice and appointing one individual to sit on the board.

The reform movement should be about much more than securing a chair for a fan. It should be about changing the way Celtic is run.

What we need around that table more than just fans are professionals who understand their respective responsibilities, who have the necessary experience and qualifications, and who can put together a coherent plan for the future of the club.

We need people capable of implementing that plan, measuring its success and accepting responsibility when things go wrong.

We need proper football leadership, professional recruitment structures, a clearly defined long-term strategy and a board that understands its responsibilities towards the institution it is supposed to serve. And, above all, we need accountability.

An elected body of the fans with the genuine power to hold directors to account if they are failing at their jobs … that’s a different proposition altogether.

If the recruitment department fails, somebody must answer for it. If the football strategy is inadequate, somebody must explain why. If the club repeatedly makes decisions that damage its sporting ambitions or its relationship with supporters, those responsible must be held accountable.

That is what professional governance looks like.

I do not want another person sitting around a table discussing the problems while nothing changes outside the boardroom.

We have had quite enough talking.

Celtic supporters have listened to statements, promises, carefully worded explanations and occasional gestures of goodwill. What we need now is evidence that the people running our club are prepared to do things differently.

Paul McStay’s suggestion is well intentioned. He is a good man, a true Celt, with the club in his heart and soul. It might sound attractive because it appears to offer a straightforward bridge between the board and the supporters. But I believe it risks presenting a superficial solution as the fix for a much deeper problem.

A fan on the board would not automatically make Celtic more transparent. It would not guarantee better recruitment, improve the football department, establish a long-term sporting strategy or make the existing directors more accountable.

And if that individual had no meaningful influence over the decisions being made, what would be the point?

I would rather see Celtic establish a genuine supporter consultation structure, with properly elected representatives from different supporter organisations, clear responsibilities and regular opportunities to challenge the board.

That would create a mechanism for supporters to be heard without pretending that one individual can speak for an entire community.

But even that would only be one part of the solution.

Celtic does not need another symbolic appointment. It needs a complete rethink of its governance and football operations.

It needs people who know what they are doing, who understand the scale of the institution they are running and who are prepared to deliver results rather than simply explain why results have not been delivered.

I respect Paul McStay, but on this occasion, I think he is looking in the wrong direction.

The problem at Celtic is not that there are too few supporters sitting around the boardroom table. The problem is that the people already sitting there have failed to convince a substantial part of the support that they have a credible plan for the future. And adding another voice to that table will not necessarily change a thing.

We want real solutions, not half-measures. We want a professional football club with professional leadership, a clear vision and a board that understands it is there to serve Celtic, not the other way around.

Paradise deserves nothing less.

Choose The CelticBlog as a Preferred Source on Google News

Paulina just relaunched her YouTube channel on all things Scottish!

You may like

Motherwell vs Rangers preview: Minsu Kim injury latest, predicted lineup and how to watch

rangersnews.uk 23 hours ago

Gareth Bale 'interested' in buying European giants after striking $1billion partnership

Wales Online 2 days ago