flag
back Atrás
Why Slugging Disappeared in the MLB Playoffs

The rate of at-bats per home run in the postseason sank to its lowest point in 12 years, while slugging decreased to a level not seen in the pitch tracking era.

The Dodgers were limited to one home run in their four-game NLCS sweep at the hands of the Brewers. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

This article is a part of Verducci’s View, a weekly baseball newsletter from Sports Illustrated senior writer Tom Verducci. Every Monday, Tom empties out his notebook over email and covers MLB’s hottest topics, provides in-depth analysis through both text and video breakdowns, looks forward to what’s worth watching during the week and more.

Home runs had been the coin of the realm in postseason baseball. The previous six World Series champions all finished among the top four in most regular season home runs. The Brewers redefined what wins in October. Last in the NL in home runs, and 28th overall, Milwaukee rode a game built on speed, contact and opposite field hitting to the title.

As Milwaukee first baseman Jake Bauers said about teams still playing the launch angle game, “It doesn’t win any more. It may work once in a while. But it’s not something that’s sustainable consistently with the way pitching is today. And when you rely on that kind of hitting, and it’s not working, you have nothing. No other way to win a game.”

Now let’s flip the coin and look at postseason baseball from the pitching perspective. We just witnessed a postseason with a record high in fastball velocity (96.1, up from 93.6 in just 10 years) and the lowest slug in the 19 seasons of pitch tracking (.336).

The rate of at-bats per home run in the postseason slowed by 35% from last year to its lowest level in 12 years:

Yearly rate of postseason at-bats per home run. | MLB

Slugging absolutely cratered this postseason to a level we had not seen in the pitch tracking era.

Yearly rate of postseason slugging percentage. | MLB

Why was it so hard to slug this postseason? Pitching is that good. The biggest causes of the lack of slug are:

  • The Brewers. With a staff built on velocity—starters who pound four-seamers and relievers who attack with power sinkers—the Brewers allowed a .243 slug, the lowest by any team that played at least three postseason games since at least 2008.
  • Velocity. Pitchers threw a record 848 pitches at 99+ mph this postseason. That’s more than in the seven postseasons between 2008–14 combined.
  • Fastballs. They are back and faster than ever. Teams threw the highest percentage of fastballs in eight postseasons (59.7%, including cutters). The slug against them hit a pitch tracking low (.354).
  • Off-speed. While breaking pitches took a sharp drop this postseason (mostly because of the Rays, who used them only 11% of the time), off-speed use has been higher the past two seasons than ever tracked. Last year was the postseason of the splitter (a record 6.8%). This year was the postseason of the changeup (a record 11.2%).

The bottom line: pitching is too good to think you are going to win just with home runs. Remember, too, the Brewers buzzed through the postseason with 13 games and 18 days off. Manager Pat Murphy could keep using his high-leverage relievers with the best stuff because his team dispatched the Padres and Dodgers in four games each, earning recharging rest in between.

Overall, this postseason teams played more games without a homer (39) and won more games without a homer (12) than in any of the past 12 postseasons. Milwaukee led the way in this low-slug environment. The Brewers went 5–0 in games in which they did not homer. Thanks to expanded playoffs, they are the first team to go 5–0 in homerless postseason games, surpassing the 1907 Cubs (4–0) and 1922 Giants (4–0).

Rays manager Kevin Cash won his second pennant this season. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Cash Exchange

In his 12th year managing the Rays, Kevin Cash showed adaptability with his personnel, as did GM Erik Neander and the front office in building the team. Typically at the head of the curve, the Rays saw pitching changing and knew offense would need to change, too. Tampa Bay morphed into a small-ball, contact heavy, risk-taking team, a methodology their analytics-heavy approach deemphasized in the past.

In 11 previous years under Cash, Tampa Bay had never been in the top half of major league teams in contact rate. Suddenly, this season they led MLB.

Rays Contact Rate Under Cash

Year

Contact%

Rank

2015

75.3%

25

2016

72.5%

30

2017

71.7%

30

2018

74.2%

21

2019

73.4%

20

2020

70.0%

29

2021

71.7%

29

2022

73.4%

23

2023

72.4%

24

2024

72.1%

26

2025

74.3%

18

2026

79.3%

1

Second baseman Brandon Lowe set many career highs on offense with the Pirates in 2026. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Buying Lowe

Coming off a career-best season, Brandon Lowe is one of the more fascinating values on the free agent market. With Pittsburgh, in the manner of Jeff Kent, Lowe provided corner-type power at second base (35 homers, 96 RBI, career bests) while improving defensively and taking the most plate appearances of his career (656). It was a huge platform season. He might be the best left-handed bat available.

But there is the age question as it relates to length of contract. As the game gets younger, buying the mid-30s years of a player, particularly in the middle infield, gets riskier. Lowe will play next season at 32. (He turns 33 in July).

Over the past eight seasons, only seven qualified middle infielders age 33 and older posted an OPS+ greater than 99. That’s less than half as many as did so in each of the three eight-season windows before this trend. The fall-off this year included the likes of Marcus Semien, Trevor Story, Xander Bogaerts, Dansby Swanson, Jake Cronenworth, Jeff McNeil and Trea Turner (all 32–35 with an OPS+ of 90 or lower).

2019–26

7

2011–18

15

2003–10

16

1995–2002

You may like

Blue Jays Predicted to Sign Free Agent Hitter to $120 Million Contract

si.com hace 47 minutos

Former Angels All-Star, Postseason Hero, Dies at 78

si.com hace 6 horas

Laying Out Some Offseason Paths to Contention for the Mets

si.com hace 47 minutos

Why Casey Mize Would Work as Fit For Cardinals

si.com hace 1 hora

Ranking the Three Worst Contracts for the Phillies Right Now

si.com hace 2 horas

Why the Cleveland Guardians Should Get Aggressive This Offseason

si.com hace 1 hora

Hellebuyck Scenario Reminiscent of Red Wings Dealings With Hasek and Joseph

aol.com hace 4 horas

White Sox Should Try to Make a Big Free Agency Splash with Seiya Suzuki

si.com hace 7 horas

One MLB Comeback Candidate Makes Plenty of Sense for Brewers

si.com hace 44 minutos