Sitting with a losing record and a coach who resides firmly on the hot seat, the New York Jets have important decisions to make in the next few weeks. First, the franchise needs to decide if it will become a seller, shipping off talented players in exchange for draft capital. If a rebuild is in the plans, no player possesses more value on the team than wide receiver Garrett Wilson. Controversial New York radio voice Craig Carton checks in with his opinion.

NY Radio Host Craig Carton Encourages Jets to Trade Garrett Wilson.

The New York Jets sit at 2-5. With a remaining schedule that features games against the Kansas City Chiefs, Denver Broncos, Minnesota Vikings, New England Patriots, and a pair against the Buffalo Bills, competing for a playoff spot looks difficult.

With the trade deadline set for November 10, the issue of whether to keep Garrett Wilson surfaces. Craig Carton, a WFAN host, pushed for team management to trade the pass catcher.

“I think the New York Jets should aggressively shop everybody they have that other teams covet, and that includes Garrett Wilson,” Carton said.

Wilson is, without a doubt, the best offensive weapon the team has. At 26, he is just entering his prime. Carton understands what Wilson brings to the table, which makes him an attractive trade chip. When the possibility of receiving a first-round pick for Wilson came up, Carton did not mince words.

“I’m trading everybody on this roster,” Carton added. “Look, I love Garrett Wilson. Three straight years of a thousand yards to start his career. Look, he got paid, which is why he’s not complaining publicly. And he did say yesterday… that obviously losing sucks, but he loves being here. He’d rather win, though.”

The radio host is referring to Wilson’s comments, which simultaneously described his loyalty to the team and his desire to start winning games.

Wilson’s frustration with the Jets’ offense was also visible last week against Miami. He went the entire first half without a target before finishing with just two catches for 26 yards, and cameras later caught him visibly upset on the sideline. ESPN subsequently reported that his frustration was directed at passing-game coordinator Seth Ryan rather than quarterback Geno Smith.

On the field, one aspect of overall improvement stands out. Wilson has caught 72.5% of his targets, which is far and away the best of his career. Carton mentioned the financial situation. From a statistical standpoint, Wilson is on pace for another 1,000-yard season. Last year, he signed a four-year, $130 million contract extension, locking him in long-term, which could be another green flag.

Several contenders could have reason to explore a deal for Wilson, especially if the Jets make him available before the deadline. The Titans’ blockbuster trade of Jeffery Simmons to the Bears for two first-round picks and a fourth-rounder, with Chicago also receiving a 2028 fifth-round pick, showed how aggressive this year’s market can be.

Wilson may not command that kind of return, but his age, production, and long-term contract could still draw significant interest from playoff hopefuls.

For example, the Kansas City Chiefs could be a potential suitor if they want another proven target for Patrick Mahomes. Rashee Rice has missed time with hamstring and knee injuries, while Xavier Worthy has carried a larger share of the receiving workload in his absence. Adding Wilson would give Kansas City another established playmaker for a postseason push.

Wilson sits at No. 15 in PFN’s NFL Wide Receiver Impact Rankings and is widely regarded as one of the league’s more talented young receivers. That combination of production, age, and long-term contract could make him one of the Jets’ most valuable trade assets if they decide to sell.

Trading away a franchise-caliber offensive weapon would be a difficult move for New York. Still, if the Jets believe they are not positioned to contend in a crowded AFC, turning Wilson into premium draft capital could help accelerate the next phase of their roster build.