flag
back Back
Second major VAR mistake in Liverpool vs Arsenal as 'clear offence' missed

Liverpool have been enraged following VAR's lack of intervention in their 1-0 defeat to Arsenal.

An image depicts a soccer match in progress, featuring three players in red uniforms standing in close proximity. One player has
Alexander Isak wanted a penalty during Liverpool's defeat to Arsenal. (Image: Getty Images)

Former Premier League referee Keith Hackett has claimed that Jurrien Timber should have been sent off in addition to a penalty being awarded for holding Alexander Isak's shirt. The former FIFA official insists the incident warranted a red card for denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.

Timber escaped punishment for preventing the Liverpool forward from connecting with a Bradley Barcola cross. Later in the match, the Arsenal defender received a yellow card following a confrontation with Alexis Mac Allister that also involved England winger Noni Madueke.

Hackett, however, is firmly of the opinion that Timber should have been walking back to the dressing room early, in addition to the penalty call being missed. He maintains the evidence speaks for itself.

The former Professional Game Match Officials (PGMO) general manager told Football Insider: "Replays at half-time showed that Jurrien Timber escaped giving away a penalty kick. The video clearly shows him holding the shirt of Liverpool player Alexander Isak.

"VAR said everything was fine, but the Arsenal man had a fistful of the top. The referee should have been invited to view the monitor; this was a clear offence, and Liverpool should have had a penalty kick."

Hackett added: "Looking at that replay again, if the penalty kick had been awarded, then Timber should have been red carded for the denial of an obvious goal-scoring opportunity."

Andoni Iraola agreed about that incident and another involving Cody Gakpo: "I think there are two situations and they are a little bit related. I think the Isak one is a clear penalty.

"He's going to head the ball in front of the goal, and they grab him where everyone sees the shirt. You don't need a lot, just to avoid Alex, because the ball just goes in front of him.

Alexander Isak claimed he was held back by Jurrien Timber inside the penalty box.
Alexander Isak claimed he was held back by Jurrien Timber inside the penalty box. (Image: Getty Images)

"I don't see why (it wasn't given); probably because he doesn't dive or go to the floor. It shouldn't be a reason not to concede a penalty."

"And then after that, the Gakpo one, I think it's a sustained holding, but I understand their argument, and I think they are right that they say the ball was too long and Cody wouldn't have arrived at the ball.

"But then you're basically accepting that the first one is a pen, no? So you cannot use the argument in both ways differently. So I think it's a, yes, it's a pen; the Alex one is..

"It's not going to change anything if we talk to the PGMOL or not. I think we have to wait now; it's 10 or 12 days until they give the resolution. It's going to be what it is, and that's it; accept it and let's go for the next one, no? It's not going to change."

You may like

CAF Women's Champions League Match Report: Ampem Darkoa Ladies hammer USFAS Bamako 5-1 in opener

kickgh.com 1 hour ago

VAR audio reveals why Tchouameni’s penalty was overturned against Racing

Prnews 3 hours ago

Cristiano Ronaldo’s Race to 1,000 Goals Handed Unwelcome Twist

si.com 3 hours ago

Javier Tebas, La Liga president; Yesterday, Kylian Mbappe's penalty was not Valid

Tilly_Writes 1 hour ago

Steven Gerrard spots Mikel Arteta hint at 'embarrassing' Liverpool penalty decision

liverpool.com 1 hour ago

Kotoko fine Diogo Peral after touchline altercation with Medeama defender

radiooneghana.com 1 hour ago

Manchester United given 'perfect' Lisandro Martinez red card verdict as appeal proposed

Standard UK 6 hours ago

Ghanaian Players Abroad: Senaya returns, Nuamah scores again, Kudus named MOTM

Pulse.com.gh 6 hours ago

Ligue 1 McDonald’s MD9 Recap: PSG extend lead as Nice thrash Rennes, Lyon and Marseille record wins

Pulse.com.gh 3 hours ago

Outstanding Kudus named Man of the Match

Graphic Online 4 hours ago