According to a report by Metro on Tuesday, October 27, 2026, former Manchester United midfielder Paul Scholes has criticised club captain Bruno Fernandes for publicly questioning the team’s tactical approach, warning that his comments could have damaged his relationship with the manager and coaching staff.

Scholes’ reaction followed Manchester United’s disappointing 4-1 Champions League defeat to Como in Italy, during which Fernandes reportedly expressed dissatisfaction with the team’s tactics. The former midfielder believes the Portuguese international should have handled his concerns privately rather than publicly challenging the approach adopted by the coaching staff.

The former United star also questioned whether other managers would be comfortable appointing Fernandes as captain after the incident. He expressed disappointment with the midfielder’s conduct, suggesting that his decision to speak publicly could negatively affect how he is perceived by other clubs and managers.

Scholes reportedly found Fernandes’ comments difficult to forgive, particularly given the responsibilities associated with being a team captain. He questioned how the midfielder could expect another manager to trust him with a leadership position after openly criticising his current manager’s tactical decisions. Scholes also suggested that a move away from European football, potentially to Saudi Arabia, could become an option for Fernandes.

Fernandes’ reported frustration centred on United’s defensive approach against Como, especially the team’s failure to apply more aggressive pressure on individual opponents. His remarks sparked discussions about whether disagreements had developed between the captain and Michael Carrick’s coaching staff, with the club already experiencing difficulties in maintaining consistent performances.

The controversy intensified when Fernandes was excluded from Manchester United’s starting line-up for Sunday’s Premier League encounter against Bournemouth. The midfielder remained on the substitutes’ bench throughout the match as United struggled to create meaningful opportunities and eventually suffered a disappointing 3-0 defeat at Old Trafford.

However, there has been no confirmation that Fernandes’ omission was directly connected to his earlier criticism of the team’s tactics. His absence nevertheless raised further questions about his position within the squad and his relationship with the coaching staff.

Scholes’ criticism has added to the wider debate about the responsibilities of a football captain, particularly during difficult periods. Captains are generally expected to demonstrate leadership, maintain constructive communication with managers and help preserve unity within the dressing room.

Meanwhile, Manchester United continue to face pressure following a reported eight-match winless run across all competitions. Carrick will be hoping to improve the team’s fortunes when United face Chelsea in the Premier League on Saturday.

Fernandes will be eager to put the controversy behind him and contribute positively to the team’s recovery. Nevertheless, questions surrounding his leadership, public criticism and relationship with the coaching staff are likely to remain a major talking point as United prepare for their next fixture.