According to a report by Football London on Wednesday November 4, 2026, Chelsea supporters are urging Xabi Alonso to replace Wesley Fofana with Aaron Anselmino against Sunderland, following the French defender’s recent mistakes and growing concerns about his performances in Chelsea’s defence this season at present.

Chelsea’s defensive choices are limited, with Maxence Lacroix injured, Jorrel Hato absent from Wednesday’s training and Josh Acheampong often deployed at right-back. Levi Colwill is expected to retain his starting place for Sunday.

Alonso must decide who partners Colwill, with Acheampong potentially moving centrally, Marco Palestra covering right-back, or Tayo Subuloye receiving an opportunity. However, many supporters believe Anselmino deserves serious consideration instead of Fofana closely.

Fofana’s recent display against Liverpool intensified criticism after he conceded a penalty and missed one himself. He also surrendered possession to Amad Diallo, leaving Chelsea fortunate to avoid another costly concession this season.

Supporters additionally remember Fofana’s dismissal during last season’s 2-1 defeat at Sunderland, which contributed to Chelsea missing European qualification. They therefore want Alonso to select Anselmino for the upcoming return fixture this weekend.

The Argentine has not featured for Chelsea since the Club World Cup, having spent loan spells at Borussia Dortmund and Strasbourg. Injuries disrupted his progress, including a problem during Chelsea’s Asian tour earlier.

Fans welcomed his return to training, believing his strength in duels, pace and uncompromising defending could suit Alonso’s preferred high defensive line and help Chelsea press opponents aggressively across the pitch this season.

Although Anselmino starting on Sunday appears uncertain, his Argentina call-up for November alongside Emi Martinez and Valentin Barco suggests encouraging progress. His return could provide Alonso with an important defensive alternative there.

Fofana’s statistics may indicate that criticism has been excessive, but Anselmino’s renewed availability offers Chelsea another option. Alonso must decide whether to trust the youngster or continue selecting the experienced Frenchman instead currently.