flag
back Back
Celtic is right not to go along with the SFA’s latest daft “development” strategy.

Celtic is right to reject pressure to support the SFA's latest daft idea.

2025 Wolrd Cup Qualifying Football Scotland v Belarus Oct 12th
12th October 2025; Hampden Park, Glasgow, Scotland; World Cup Qualifiers International Football, Scotland versus Belarus; Keep clear until kick off sign at the side of the pitch

I had to smile when I heard Martin O’Neill being asked yesterday about the Scottish FA scaling back its plans to introduce more young players into the senior game. His response, or rather his lack of one, was quite revealing.

He did not really have an answer because he was not following the story particularly closely. And why would he be? The Celtic manager has considerably more important things to worry about than keeping up with another SFA initiative that may or may not make any difference to Scottish football.

But I want to focus on something rather more interesting here.

O’Neill’s reaction perfectly illustrates why these proposals were always going to struggle. Some of the people who were supposed to implement this grand strategy were never particularly enthusiastic about it in the first place. And without their cooperation, what exactly did the SFA expect to achieve?

Let me explain.

The fundamental problem with the SFA’s approach is that it seems to believe that introducing more young players into senior football is simply a matter of issuing instructions, establishing targets and expecting clubs to fall into line.

Apparently, somebody in an office has decided that Scottish football needs more youngsters playing first-team football, and therefore clubs should somehow make it happen.

Wonderful! Another brilliant idea from the people who have been responsible for overseeing Scottish football for years. What could possibly go wrong?

I am not arguing against giving young Scottish footballers opportunities.

Quite the opposite. I want to see talented youngsters coming through at Celtic. I want our academy players to be developed properly, given meaningful opportunities and eventually become important members of the first team. I would be delighted to see more Scottish youngsters establishing themselves at the highest level. I have written in recent days about how it is time to give Clearie a run in the team.

However, there is a difference between encouraging clubs to develop young players and effectively expecting managers to fulfil some sort of youth quota. And that distinction seems to have escaped the people dreaming up these proposals.

The original plans included compulsory under-21 selections in cup competitions and targets for playing minutes in the Premiership.

Whatever the precise mechanism, the same fundamental question arises: should administrators be determining how managers use their squads?

Let me put myself in a manager’s position.

I have a squad to manage, injuries to deal with, tactical problems to solve, supporters demanding results, and a league campaign that could determine my future. I have to prepare for matches, analyse opponents, manage experienced professionals and make decisions that could cost me my job.

And somewhere in the middle of all that, the SFA comes along and tells me that I should be introducing more youngsters into my team. Excuse me?

A manager’s responsibility is to select the strongest possible team available to him. His responsibility is to win football matches, compete for trophies and protect his club’s interests. He is not employed to become the experimental laboratory manager for an administrative strategy developed by people who do not have to face the consequences when things go wrong.

Because what happens when a young player is introduced before he is ready? What happens when an inexperienced defender makes a costly mistake in a crucial match? What happens when a manager drops an established professional to accommodate a youngster simply because somebody has decided that the numbers are not looking good enough?

Who takes responsibility? The SFA? I would not hold my breath.

The manager takes the criticism. The club loses out. The supporters become frustrated. And the young footballer, who might have benefited from another year of development, suddenly finds himself under enormous pressure.

That is not youth development. That is potentially damaging young players in the name of satisfying an administrative target.

And I refuse to pretend that this is a sensible way of doing things.

There is another problem.

Why would any club volunteer to become the first guinea pig in this experiment? Football is competitive. Managers are judged on results, not on how many teenagers they manage to squeeze into their starting eleven. Clubs have financial interests, sporting ambitions and supporters who expect them to compete.

Nobody is going to volunteer to jeopardise those interests simply because the SFA has decided that it would make an interesting development project. And that is precisely why these proposals were always doomed to encounter resistance.

The SFA seems to have underestimated the reality of professional football. You cannot simply introduce a new requirement and expect everyone to embrace it. Clubs have different financial situations, different academies, different squad requirements and different ambitions. What works for one club might be completely inappropriate for another.

Celtic, for example, have an academy structure and a responsibility to develop talented youngsters. But that does not mean we should be forced to play somebody before our coaching staff believe he is ready. I want to see our young players progress because they deserve their opportunities, not because an administrator somewhere has decided that Celtic need to improve a particular statistic.

There is a difference between opportunity and obligation. The former can produce footballers. The latter can produce resentment.

And perhaps the SFA should spend a little more time considering why young Scottish players are not progressing as successfully as they should rather than looking for another convenient way to shift responsibility onto clubs.

Are our coaching structures sufficiently developed? Are young players receiving the right technical education? Are academies properly supported? Are there enough opportunities for meaningful competitive football at different stages of development? Are clubs being encouraged to invest in coaching and facilities?

These are the questions worth asking.

Developing footballers requires patience, expertise, investment and a coherent long-term strategy. It requires cooperation between the SFA, clubs, academies and coaches. Most importantly, it requires understanding that every young player develops differently. You cannot put a stopwatch on potential.

Martin O’Neill might not have been following the latest SFA proposals, but I suspect his reaction was more revealing than any lengthy statement from the governing body. Managers have their own responsibilities, and they are not going to rearrange their entire professional priorities to accommodate another initiative from Hampden.

I would rather have a manager who understands when a youngster is ready than one who introduces him simply to keep an administrator happy.

So, yes, I want more Scottish youngsters playing senior football. I want better pathways, better coaching and clubs that genuinely invest in their academies. But I also want common sense.

The SFA should be creating the conditions in which young players can flourish, not attempting to dictate how managers select their teams.

And perhaps that is the biggest lesson here.

If you want clubs to develop young footballers, give them the support, resources and incentives to do so. Build a system that makes it worthwhile. Work with managers rather than treating them as obstacles to your latest grand plan.

Because issuing demands from an office is easy. Developing the next generation of Scottish footballers is considerably harder.

And if the SFA has not worked that out by now, I am afraid there is very little hope for its next bright idea.

Scottish football needs genuine leadership, not another quota dressed up as a development strategy.

Choose The CelticBlog as a Preferred Source on Google News

You may like

Bryson claims 'sectarian witch hunt' as Rangers supporters club probed over Belfast tournament ra...

newsletter.co.uk 1 day ago

Torreense face Benfica and Celtic in four days

vitalfootball.co.uk 6 hours ago

Celtic Teenager Demands O’Neill’s Attention After Historic Goal Streak

celtsarehere.com 1 day ago

Aiden McGeady urges Celtic to target better players

glasgowtimes.co.uk 1 hour ago

He Played For Man Utd and Liverpool - Then Was Banned From Football For Racist Remarks

givemesport.com 17 hours ago

Evander Holyfield sums up Anthony Joshua’s chances of beating Tyson Fury to become three-time cha...

boxingnewsonline.net 3 hours ago

Premiership clubs fear major youth academy cuts with six-figure SFA funding drop looming

Daily Record 23 hours ago