Back
Bernard Jackman has criticised the ‘moral police’ while expressing sympathy for Rassie Erasmus, arguing that referee Andrea Piardi appeared reluctant to make a decision that would cost France the game.
As an ex-head coach, Jackman fully understands Erasmus’ frustration with World Rugby, which he feels is going down a ‘slippery path’ with the constant law changes that referees are struggling to keep up with.
This is particularly the case after World Rugby implemented two law changes before the start of the second leg of the Nations Championship, giving players and referees little time to adjust.
“I feel for him as an ex-coach and a rugby pundit and commentator,” the Irishman told SuperSport.
“The game is going down a slippery path in terms of TMO decisions, lack of consistency, and clarity around certain things.
“New laws were brought in the middle of one of the most pressurised times for players. If you look at how many head-high contacts we have in games, and for the last four years we’ve been trying to clamp down on those, and suddenly you bring in knee-drops and hip-drops in the middle of a tournament without any real time to adapt to it.
“I think referees are already struggling with the game as it was, never mind two new laws.”
Focusing on the match that sparked Erasmus‘ outrage, Jackman said Italian referee Piardi didn’t want to award South Africa a penalty that could have led to France’s defeat at the Stade de France.
While he can understand that led to frustration, he added that once Erasmus said ‘match-fixing’, World Rugby were left with no choice but to intervene.
“So look, when you look back at that… even when you watch that game live, you certainly felt at the end that Piardi didn’t want to make a decision that would cost France the game,” he continued.
“As a head coach, you want to give your team the best possible chance of winning – you expect fair play. So I can understand why Rassie was so frustrated.
“I think the word match-fixing took it to a level where World Rugby had to step in, but I do feel for him, and Rassie’s job is to get the best out of his players, protect them, and make sure South Africa have the best chance of winning a third World Cup.”
“He is a genius,” Jackman continued. “And it’s probably a management tactic to give his players motivation to focus their minds, and if South Africa win a third World Cup in 20 years’ time, no one’s going to be talking about a six-match ban.
“They’re going to be talking about how they keep this team for 12 years to be at the top.”
While Erasmus’ choice of words left World Rugby no choice, Jackman still thinks that those condemning him have overreacted.
“People are moral police, but the reality is he said something in a press conference; no one’s dead. It’s not the end of the world. He’s been banned. Let the players do the talking now on Saturday.”
Former Springboks hooker Hanyani Shimange appeared on the show along with Jackman and has taken issue with World Rugby sanctioning Erasmus without a hearing and midway through the Nations Championship.
He added that the Bok coach is not alone in being frustrated by the game’s governing body but is the first to speak up so forthrightly.
“I can guarantee you every coach feels the same after the game. And the reality is, it builds up until someone says something. Rassie just happens to be the guy who’s actually spoken out,” he said.
He also agreed with Jackman’s verdict on Piardi’s performance: “I don’t want to go on about it, but it’s well said on social media, but it wasn’t a good refereeing performance.
“For me, it’s the lack of transparency. If World Rugby had come out Monday and said, ‘It wasn’t a good reffing performance; you got X, Y, Z wrong’, then you move on.
“The fact that no one says anything is a big issue because then the coaches don’t have an outlet that’s five clips. So how do you communicate these things then? Coaches get paid big salaries; their jobs are on the line, so there are a lot of consequences outside of that.”
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
Erasmus will be absent from the coaches’ box for South Africa’s clash with Ireland in Dublin this weekend and possibly the Nations Championship Finals Weekend in Twickenham, depending on when his full misconduct hearing takes place.
“The timing of the ban is a big thing. They could have said, ‘Let’s wait until the competition is over; he is being investigated; we will deal with it post the competition, not during a Test match week’,” he added.
“The automatic ban without a hearing; it just doesn’t sit well with me.”
If Erasmus fails to get his ban expunged, he will also be absent from the first four rounds of next year’s Rugby Championship.