flag
back Back
Schalk Burger: Refs are a ‘protected species’, World Rugby must ‘grow some balls’
Referee Andrea Piardi and an inset of Springboks legend Schalk Burger.
Referee Andrea Piardi and an inset of Springboks legend Schalk Burger.

Schalk Burger says World Rugby must ‘grow some balls’ and make referees accountable for their performances.

The legendary Springboks flanker doesn’t see anything wrong with Rassie Erasmus calling out the officiating in South Africa’s defeat to France and was incredibly critical of Italian referee Andrea Piardi.

He argues that the officials are the lowest-paid participants on matchday and wants them to be paid more, with the caveat that they then are fully responsible for their performances.

Schalk Burger’s rant post-Rassie Erasmus’ ban

“Is it a bad thing to say anything? Like, we’ve seen Dave Rennie speak out quite a lot; Eddie Jones is renowned for it,” Burger said on the Boks Unpacked podcast before he was interrupted by fellow Springboks legend Jean de Villiers.

“For context again,” the ex-centre began. “Dave Rennie was saying that the Boks walked around in the scrum and they’re not getting penalised… is that not saying exactly the same [as Rassie] but just in a different way?

“It’s Rassie’s second language, out of context, saying something a lot in a lot harsher way, but it comes down to the same principle, right?”

Burger continued his rant, saying: “For me, is it wrong to say anything? I don’t think World Rugby needs to be in a position where you’re not allowed to criticise each other.

“The referees have been a protected species since we’ve been playing, and that’s part of my frustration. You look at 30 players on the field; the guy on the smallest salary there is the referee who has got the biggest impact on the game, and I’ve for a long time been saying, like, pay them, make them equal pay to all the players, but then full accountability.”

Coaches are fired for underperforming at the highest level, and players are dropped, with Burger pointing to the fact that Manie Libbok has been omitted from the Springboks matchday 23 to face Ireland after missing a conversion against France.

He believes that a similar fate should fall on those who officiated at the Stade de France: “Why should anyone on that refereeing panel from last week be featuring this week? You’ve got to be held accountable for your actions, which, unfortunately, is not the case in our game.

“Referees get away with it, and they’ll be blowing the next game – Piardi will be scheduled for a Springbok game again next week. Even though our last two matches [with him] have been bizarre, to say the least.

“World Rugby just needs to grow a pair of balls, and if there’s criticism, it’s coming from a good place.”

Has rugby stopped being a debate?

While many commentators and former players have berated Erasmus for his comments and claims of match-fixing, Burger was firmly on the defence for the Springboks head coach. He believes that the issues with World Rugby’s constant law changes have been the main contributor to Erasmus’ frustration.

He adds that Erasmus is correct to push back and thinks others should too, instead of simply accepting all explanations.

“For me, when has rugby stopped being a debate? It has to be. Like that’s the only way the game’s going to improve,” Burger said.

“We can’t just take whatever has been given to us as gospel; remember in our time we played under ELVs, experimental law variations, that was a shocker. It was given to us as players to trial. It was so bad that the Northern Hemisphere never played it. We played it in one Super Rugby and one Tri-Nations.”

Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.

“Players, coaches, referees, and World Rugby have all got to sit around a table and figure it out,” he continued.

“The main frustration comes from knee-drop and hip-drop tackles: you coach your players specifically not to do that tackle technique and find a new way to disrupt teams on attack, and then you play against a team that doesn’t knee-drop, and nothing gets done about it, and the referee and his panel then say it’s simultaneous.

“Every time it’s a knee drop, it’s simultaneous 17 times in a row – that’s what triggered everyone involved.”

You may like

Sir Steve Hansen makes thoughts clear on Rassie Erasmus ban

ruck.co.uk 2 days ago

‘Piardi didn’t want to cost France’ – Bernard Jackman feels for Rassie and hits out at ‘moral pol...

planetrugby.com 7 hours ago

World Rugby make Malcolm Marx ban decision after footage emerges

ruck.co.uk 12 hours ago

Schalk Burger: Referee ‘bailed out the contest’ as disallowed Springboks try dubbed ‘ridiculously...

planetrugby.com 2 days ago

'Don't mess this up!' The man Wales let inside as chaos erupted and tears flowed

Wales Online 8 hours ago

Canada vs Romania

rugby365.com 4 hours ago

England and New Zealand collide with final spots and reputations on the line

The Guardian 1 hour ago