flag
back Back
Schalk Burger: Referee ‘bailed out the contest’ as disallowed Springboks try dubbed ‘ridiculously pedantic’
Springboks scrum versus France and an inset of Schalk Burger.
Springboks scrum versus France and an inset of Schalk Burger.

Schalk Burger believes that referee Andrea Piardi bailed out of officiating the scrum in South Africa’s defeat to France in the Nations Championship and has hit out at Kurt-Lee Arendse’s disallowed try.

The Springboks had dominance in the set-piece throughout the clash at the Stade de France, but when the hosts were on a team warning after repeated infringements, the Italian official opted not to issue a yellow card to the French despite their pack conceding another penalty.

Instead, he issued one soon after but in a less threatening part of the pitch for Les Bleus. That was a crucial moment in the game, according to the former flanker who reviewed some of the controversial moments in the match on the Verdict show, which was hosted by fellow former Springbok Jean de Villiers and Junior Boks coach Kevin Foote.

Definitely a yellow card

During the ‘controversy corner’ segment of the show, De Villiers asked whether Aaron Grandidier-Nkanang deserved a yellow card and if a further sanction was warranted for his deliberate knock-down.

“Yes, definitely. Definitely yellow,” Foote replied.

Burger added that he didn’t think it was worthy of a penalty try. “That’s the way it’s, it’s a yellow. I think there was someone in the backfield in the wider channel,” he said.

Foote agreed: “No, I was thinking at home it could be a penalty try. That has to be clear and obvious that they’re going to get there, and we had two on the outside.

“If they had given a penalty try, I wouldn’t have argued against it. Maybe I’m biased, but I can also see the cover. It wasn’t a massive talking point during the game.”

Quickly moving on, De Villiers turned to Arendse’s try in the first half, with the winger’s score chalked off after a TMO review deemed him to have not been 10 metres back from the lineout when Malcolm Marx overthrew the lineout.

“Was Arendse’s disallowed ridiculously pedantic?” De Villiers asked.

“Yes,” Foote promptly replied. “I would say that happens all the time, and if you set that precedent, then you have to stick to it.”

Burger added: “I was about to say when last did the attacking team get a try disallowed for breaking the ten?”

“That’s ridiculous,” Foote added.

Burger was even more critical about the TMO: “He decides to come in there, but then where there’s absolutely zero tolerance on knee drops and hip drops – we’ve seen that so far, nothing.

“You don’t see that doesn’t come in, or you don’t come in on a scrum infringement or offside infringement. You pick that moment as your moment to come in. It just doesn’t quite sit well with me.”

Kurt-Lee Arendse’s ruled out try

De Villiers said that while Arendse’s was ruled not to have been 10 metres back, he argued that it’s a “judgment call”, while Burger argued that it should be a call the assistant referee makes as they usually set the mark for the defence.

“We shall leave it at that,” De Villiers said before moving onto the scrum debate where Burger was forthright in his verdict.

“No. He just bailed out the contest,” the former flanker said when asked whether Piardi ‘completely lost control of the scrums’.

“You can’t have a five-metre scrum; scrum has been one-way traffic, put the French on a team warning, then after that, give a penalty and say, ‘That’s not a team warning because he can’t figure out the individual.’ Yes, it was. It was number 18, the tighthead, and then after that, the same picture happens again, and then you say, ‘No, but now we got to play away’ because it’s now not a penalty the fifth time.

“I don’t quite get it, but then when it doesn’t matter the next following scrum, you give a yellow card outside the Boks 22. Then with a kickable penalty in the 78th minute, then you go, ‘Okay, now it’s changed again, play away’.”

Scrum debate

De Villiers then posed the question to Foote of whether the Boks are too reliant on the scrum, particularly because it is one of the facets of the game where it’s so easy for officials to bail out and not make a decision, and that there’s really no accountability for that?

“I think it’s a hard one, now, to make a call in at that moment, especially in France with that crowd,” Foote replied.

“It had to be the call. He had put them on a warning. Look, our strategy is scrum. I thought Rassie was a hell of a mature and humble guy in his post-match. He said we’re human. We make mistakes, and maybe we shouldn’t have gone for the scrum.

“But if we had got the penalty, maybe even a penalty try there, with that yellow card, we wouldn’t be saying that. I think that we back our system the same way France did. They went with a smaller pack. They played with high tempo. They didn’t go to the lineout. That was their strategy, and it worked for them.

“Our strategy is we’re going to scrum you, and we didn’t get the reward. When he said team warning, of course, we’re going to go for scrum.

“You can argue why not the maul or argue anything; the reality is it’s our weapon. It didn’t come to fruition, and we got to look at that because it did happen against New Zealand in the first Test.

“We got a turnover there, and maybe we should look at that and say, go to the maul. But I would say I don’t blame anyone; if we got momentum there, the ref put them on a warning. I would have done the Pieter-Steph ‘Where do we scrum?’

He added: “And Malcolm was doing this [signalling for a scrum], when your leader of your pack is doing this, as a coach, I’d say back him.”

Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.

Speaking in the aftermath of the defeat, Springboks boss Rassie Erasmus also addressed his team’s reliance on the scrum.

“It’s probably a cliché, but I definitely think we had enough opportunities and there were simple tries we could have scored with one last pass, and perhaps one or two wrong decisions, such as not kicking for the corner and rather expecting the referee to give four penalties in a row,” he said.

“In front of a crowd like this you might feel you have dominance, but it’s just human not to keep on penalising the home team if they’ve already got a card or two. But in the end, it comes down to the fact that they played well, and we didn’t.”

You may like

World Rugby launch investigation into Springboks after wild 'match-fixing' rant

Wales Online 3 days ago

Schalk Burger: Refs are a ‘protected species’, World Rugby must ‘grow some balls’

planetrugby.com 5 hours ago

Andy Farrell responds to controversial Springboks decision

ruck.co.uk 2 days ago

Nations Championship permutations: How France, England, Ireland, the All Blacks and Springboks ca...

planetrugby.com 3 days ago

Springboks demand World Rugby action as Ireland accusation made on eve of game

Wales Online 5 hours ago

All Blacks: Jordie Barrett reveals why Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry series against Springboks was a ‘...

planetrugby.com 11 hours ago

France team v Argentina: Matthieu Jalibert among four changes from Springboks victory

planetrugby.com 1 day ago

Rassie Erasmus could walk away from Springboks for good after latest ban

ruck.co.uk 2 days ago