flag
back Back
Loose Pass: A lack of class, pre-match spectacles, southern takeaways and nudges
Rassie Erasmus and All Blacks haka image
Springboks boss Rassie Erasmus and Rieko Ioane leads the All Blacks haka against Wales in Cardiff (inset).

This week we will mostly be concerning ourselves with a lack of class, spectacles, southern takeaways and nudges…

Was the book thrown hard enough?

It’s close to impossible to understand what Rassie Erasmus was thinking when he let loose on Monday, but it did not take long for the book to arc through the air from World Rugby’s masters. Yet while six games does encompass a fair chunk of South Africa’s season, will it really have much of an effect? After all, he can still coach the team through the next few months, he’ll still be talking to the fans and still curating his cult status as South Africa’s eternally right. Or is that self-righteous?

Either way, it’s a little difficult not to hark back to a few months ago when this column became a pariah among the South Africans for supposedly insinuating that Rassie was like Donald Trump. That time it was a comparison all to do with his modus operandum of deflection and political chicanery, nothing about his personality.

Yet now, here we have someone who, having suffered a tight defeat against a significant adversary, refuses to accept it was anything but corruption. And here, also, is Donald Trump. Here’s a bloke followed through thick and thin by unwavering loyal fans who embrace his every word and heap furious scorn on his every official adversary, doing his smearing work for him. And here, also, is Donald Trump.

He is doing his country and his talented team a tremendous disservice. Fans hang on his every word – who wouldn’t when there are two World Cups in the cabinet – but with that comes a responsibility to the game and its fans which is now being abused. Such a crass inability to suck up the occasional thing that doesn’t go your way seeps through; as a spectator in the stands on Friday, Loose Pass found a disproportionate number of South African fans’ behaviour abhorrent, not least the bloke who responded with a frothy-mouthed shower of swear-words and all but fisticuffs when he perceived that a local might have got to a urinal first, but unfairly. It was not all the fans of course, but little aspects like that were far too noticeable around the place.

He simply does not understand, or acknowledge this responsibility. Will it take an actual attack on a referee by a fan to make him understand? Or fighting in the stands? How long before another Pieter van Zyl, when even one of the great coaches of the modern era cannot accept that a defeat was anything other than corruption and an agenda against the team by the officials and governing body?

Either way, there’s no defence for what he has said. Neither in interpretation, nor intent, nor mitigation. Even in the press briefing itself he said that he was not making an accusation about the officials, having literally with the previous breath asked those present a rhetorical question about match-fixing. Perhaps it comes short of the underhand instigation of the keyboard mob trial of Nic Berry but given that previous, it’s slightly surprising that he is not banned for longer, or from all rugby activities and not just matchday ones.

A great coach, a great rugby mind and a great competitor. His team and players and the vast proportion of his countrymen are a class act; they deserve to be led with similar class.

What a pair of spectacles!

Rassie’s recommendation for officials? No. The performances of their respective teams stood up to the billing, but when it comes to winners of the weekend, the lighting riggers and pyrotechnic setters of the stadia in Paris and Cardiff were miles ahead of any of their counterparts.

The red wall will forever be etched into haka folklore, and would have been so even had the team not lived up to the mesmerising imagery the dry ice and red lanterns conjured up. The Stade de France’s dancing drones before the game, and its snowflake effects during the half-time, continue a tradition of Paris being a benchmark for a spectacle on rugby nights.

As games edge ever further into three-digit ticket prices, you can shout this far and wide: you’ll get the full show in Paris and Cardiff.

Difficult Mondays

Rassie had a difficult Monday for sure, but spare a thought for Dave Rennie, who saw all progress made since the onset of his tenure dashed to pieces against said red wall in a shock defeat that, from some statistical angles, is greater even than Japan’s defeat of South Africa in 2015.

Leaving aside the fact that Rennie and pretty much every Kiwi fan reacted with grimly-determined class, most also pin-pointed pretty quickly one of the self-inflicted reasons for the defeat: a regression almost to 2007 type where the game-plan was the plan, which was the plan, and other options, such as attacking some occasionally bare edges were seemingly not considered.

Whatever the vast, dragon-sized lump of credit to be bestowed upon the hosts, it was remarkable to see senior All Blacks players make narrow decisions under pressure, make offloads for the sake of offloading, fail to see spaces elsewhere but the channels in front. Rennie promised tough chats in team meetings, rather than press conferences, but South Africa had their own achilles heel.

How many times did the inside defender from the French line accelerate to the heels of the wrap-around distributor taking the ball wide and allow his line to shift, in turn allowing France’s wingers to shoot in and shut down the space? It was read and shut down at least six times, and South Africa seemed to have no plan B other than slowing the game down and resorting to mauls and scrums.

Rassie can moan all he wants, but like New Zealand, South Africa had enough quality possession to win and did not find the variations on a theme to make it count.

Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.

Nudge, nudge

So, to continue on a theme of numerous incidents of a similar nature missed by officials: how many times did South African kick-chasers nudge, bump or shoulder a French would-be kick receiver out of the way before the ball came to catching height on Friday?

• Law 9.13 (Early/Late/Dangerous Tackle): Prohibits tackling an opponent early, late, or dangerously.

• Law 9.14 (Tackle Without the Ball): Prohibits tackling an opponent who does not possess the ball.

Application and Sanctions

• Grounded Receiver: Contact before the ball arrives violates Laws 9.13 and 9.14, resulting in a penalty kick.

• Obstruction: Simply blocking or shoving a receiver without a tackle attempt is penalized

I mean, it might not have been 17 times, but if it came around, it went around.

You may like

Nations Championship Finals Weekend fixtures – as it stands

ruck.co.uk 1 day ago

Brian O’Driscoll admits Rassie Erasmus has a point

ruck.co.uk 2 days ago

Live Ireland squad announcement: Andy Farrell to name team to play South Africa

irishtimes.com 3 days ago

Nations Championship deliver verdict on Sam Prendergast citing

rugbypass.com 4 days ago

Jasper Wiese banned by World Rugby with immediate effect

ruck.co.uk 4 days ago

Springboks demand World Rugby action as Ireland accusation made on eve of game

Wales Online 1 day ago

Nick Mallett: Rassie should never have said that – ‘I don’t know how he can defend himself’

planetrugby.com 4 days ago

Siya Kolisi: 'It may sound dramatic to you, but to us it means so much more'

rugbypass.com 1 day ago

Malcolm Marx faces potential ban as France incident emerges

ruck.co.uk 3 days ago