Back
I don’t want to be too harsh on former Celtic players. But there are a handful of them in the mainstream media who will certainly enjoy better media careers than they did football ones, because their contribution, at least as far as Celtic goes, was so inconsequential as to be ridiculous.
Scott Allan barely had a Celtic career.
His signing was baffling to me.
I was so sure that he would not be signed by Celtic that, on what turned out to be the eve of his signing, I said I would eat a concrete mixer full of humble pie if the deal happened. I’m still working my way through that task today.
On a more serious note, I still believe that he was signed merely to spite the Ibrox club, who were trying to sign him and couldn’t scramble together the funds necessary to do it. The manager certainly did not want him and did not use him.
I couldn’t see where he fitted into the team at the time. I didn’t think he was good enough to be a Celtic player, and my view at the time and since has never changed. We should have let them have him. What exactly would have been the point of blocking their signing of a player who just wasn’t that great?
And this is why I love it when I hear Scott Allan being touted as a former Celtic player and spoken of in those kinds of hushed tones, as though having trained at Lennoxtown makes him an expert on all things to do with this club.
I don’t mind the guy usually, but if he wants to tread onto our terrain, then I’m sorry, but I’m going to have to treat him like everybody else.
His comments the other day about Celtic fans supposedly dropping our own standards because we’re not giving Kasper Høgh a harder time, and because we praised him for his last performance despite his failure to score, taking his run without a goal to 18 games, are worth examining.
Here’s what Allan said:
“Kasper Hogh, I found that quite strange after the game. Because I saw a lot of Celtic fans happy with how he played. I just felt, ‘Is that the bar now?’ A couple of good touches and setting it back. It’s what I would expect for the money you have spent on a Celtic number nine. It’s all the things I would expect him to do.”
Well, I want to say something to Scott Allan. Celtic’s standards were in decline long before Kasper Høgh arrived. The fact that Allan arrived at all was one of the earliest proofs of that. And like I said, I don’t mean to be harsh, but sometimes you’ve got to be cruel to be kind, and that’s one of the nicer things I could have said.
But let’s examine the substance of what he’s saying, because I find it an extraordinary way to look at things.
What exactly is Allan suggesting? That Celtic supporters should refuse to acknowledge a good performance from a striker unless he scores? That we should ignore the things he does well because he hasn’t yet delivered what we ultimately expect from him?
I have been as critical as anybody of the decision to spend £11 million on Kasper Høgh when we aren’t getting the best out of him, but I am perfectly capable of recognising when the guy has played well. Those two positions are not remotely contradictory.
Praising a player’s performance is not the same thing as lowering your expectations of him. Nobody is suddenly pretending that Høgh’s scoring record is acceptable. Nobody is suggesting that a handful of decent touches and some good link-up play justify an £11 million transfer fee.
But as Paulina has said over the past week, and I agree with her, he didn’t set that fee himself. That’s what our club deemed he was worth.
What supporters are acknowledging is that, in a team which has struggled badly for fluency and attacking cohesion, Høgh actually contributed something positive. We want to see more of that, and we certainly want to see goals. But I refuse to accept that encouraging a player who has been struggling somehow represents a collapse in Celtic’s standards.
Maybe it’s just me, but I was brought up as a football fan to believe that when a player is struggling, you try to give him as much encouragement as you can. Anytime Scott Allan played in the Celtic team, we tried to give him encouragement. It wasn’t often, but we tried to encourage him whenever he did.
And the problem with Kasper is that he’s arrived for a club-record fee, which brings its own pressure straight away. Adam Idah scored a lot of goals for Celtic, and there was a section of the fanbase that never took to him and never accepted him.
So, it’s not even all about goals. The media is never going to give a Celtic player who is not doing well an easy time of it. Never. It just doesn’t happen.
Let me put it another way.
The Ibrox club’s Korean winger, in spite of being copiously lauded in the media, has not scored a goal and has not even assisted one since signing for the club. Is he under pressure? Of course not. In fact, he’s getting rave reviews.
Celtic players are judged differently.
It has always been the case. It will always be the case. And especially a guy who has signed for that much money. He is always going to get stick.
And look, I probably shouldn’t be singling Scott Allan out. He’s by no means alone here. During the half-time break in a recent game, Kasper’s entire performance was being dissected based on how many touches he had outside the box.
Outside the box. This is not what you expect your striker to do.
But had he been inside the box and got no touches, because we seemed incapable that night of putting the ball anywhere near the penalty area, would he have received better coverage? Or would it have been worse?
As it turned out, on the night in question, I thought he actually had a very good first half. But this is the problem. If all you’re doing is judging the guy on goals, you’re missing everything else that he does.
If he was making no contribution at all, I could understand him getting pilloried. I could understand him getting crucified. But that’s not the case.
And whilst I recognise that a striker who has gone 18 games without a goal badly needs one, it does not mean that you cannot appreciate everything else he’s doing in a match.
It does make me question whether we know the type of player we signed, whether we had a plan for playing to his strengths. And in the end, I still think he’ll come good. He’s got too much quality not to.
For all I give stick to the mainstream media as a whole, it’s not the Hugh Keevins and the Tom English’s of this world who are giving the big guy the hardest time. It’s ex-Celtic players who know what the pressure is like at Celtic, who know that players here are scrutinised differently, who know that the media is hostile, in large part, to anybody at Celtic and will use any excuse it can to pile on the pressure.
I’m not asking these guys to give him an easy ride, far less a free ride, but a little bit of understanding, a little bit of support, is surely not too much to ask. And this joker is questioning fans for giving support to a player under pressure. That just blows my mind, and that’s why I had to comment on it.
It is a strange day when the supposedly fickle fanbase of a football club is backing a player who’s not having a particularly good time.
Wow. I can understand why Allan is screeching over that one.
Choose The CelticBlog as a Preferred Source on Google News