Back
Three takeaways from Wiegman's latest Lionesses squad
Three takeaways from Wiegman's latest...
Who makes the cut?! Sky Sports'...
McGinley: Rahm suffered the most by...
'He's evolved over 10 years' - Why Poch...
Could USMNT players follow Poch to Man...
Mum's the word! Portugal boss responds...
Can Frank keep Palace up? How his...
'It's driving me mad!' - Why Bouaddi...
Has Tuchel learnt from Argentina...
Humble pie for O'Hara? 'Why do we have...
'A lot of respect' - How did the...
It’s been 12 years since any player moved directly between Newcastle United and Sunderland, and few have been brave enough to straddle both sides of the Tyne and Wear divide – but according to new transfer rumours, another player could soon make that leap, albeit with another team that wear black and white in between.
Recent reports suggest that Sunderland are in the market for defensive reinforcements this January in order to help them steer clear of the relegation battle, and one of the name to come up in dispatches has been Lloyd Kelly, who left Newcastle for Juventus in February 2025 and swiftly established himself as a regular starter in Serie A.
Kelly didn’t spend too long on Tyneside – he only made 10 league appearances for Newcastle before moving on – but he would still be the first player to play for both North East teams since Kazenga LuaLua, a decade ago, if he did make the switch. But is he really likely to sign for Sunderland in the coming months?
Sport Witness have become the latest media outlet to report on Sunderland’s alleged interest in Kelly, who have supposedly made “several advances” as they attempt to negotiate a deal for a player who has fallen out of favour in Turin this season.
Kelly has had a bit of a rollercoaster ride since signing for the Old Lady. Criticised by sections of the Italian press for his performances on loan from Newcastle during the second half of the 2024/25 season, he was nonetheless signed permanently in a deal worth €17m (£14.5m) and repaid both the faith and the fee over the course of an impressive 2025/26 campaign.
Kelly made 35 appearances in Serie A, switching between left-back and centre-back as required, and displayed the combination of defensive rigidity, technical quality and dynamism on the ball that made him stand out at Bournemouth in the first place.
Unfortunately for Kelly, his time as a first-team regular seems to have been brief. He has started just one league match this season after being sidelined by the arrival of Jhon Lucumí – ironically, a player that Sunderland tried hard to sign themselves in 2025 following promotion to the Premier League.
Their failure to land Lucumí could now create an opportunity for them to sign Kelly instead. Gazzetta dello Sport are among the Italian outlets whose recent reporting backs up the assertion that Sunderland have already opened lines of communication in the hopes of setting up a deal, and thanks to his demotion to the bench at Juventus, a transfer doesn’t seem too distant of a prospect.
Although multiple sources have now reported on Sunderland’s supposed interest in Kelly, there is still a lot of detail missing – not least in terms of how the finances of such a deal might look.
The £14.5m that Juventus paid for Kelly nearly 18 months provides a starting point, but given that he remains under contract until 2029, Juventus have plenty of leverage and could hold out for a larger sum – especially given that Kelly may only be an injury away from returning to the starting line-up.
The good news for Sunderland, however, is that Juventus are expected to look for opportunities to sell players this January as they battle to meet their obligations to UEFA’s financial fair play regulations. Gazzetta dello Sport also claim that at least one sale is “necessary” if they want to bring any new faces in, and Kelly is suggested as one of the players who could end up on the auction block.
He isn’t alone in that regard – Edon Zhegrova and Daniele Rugani are also mentioned as potential outgoings – but Juventus’ finances do increase the chances that a deal could get done.
From Sunderland’s perspective, adding a versatile defender with Premier League experience makes sense, even if he did once play for their bitter rivals. Sunderland have conceded 17 goals in their first 10 games – only four teams have shipped more – and while the lacklustre attack remains the biggest problem facing Régis Le Bris, their back four has failed to meet the high standards they set last season.
There should be a modest amount of money to spend in January, and Kelly is a player who has the combination of experience, quality and likely affordability to be a logical target. Just don’t expect in Newcastle to be kind to him if he makes the move.