Back
It has been a week of big promises across Scottish football, with Derek McInnes determined to keep Rangers’ prized assets at Ibrox, Mario Frick setting his sights on hauling Aberdeen into the top six and Callum Osmand laying down a marker over his Celtic ambitions.
But which of those declarations are destined to become reality, and where might expectation collide with the cold reality of the months ahead?
Graeme Young and David Irvine are on Burning Questions duty today as they run the rule over Rangers’ most valuable talents, assess whether Frick can really engineer an Aberdeen revival and debate whether Osmand can turn flashes of Celtic promise into a permanent place in the starting XI.
Graeme Young: Olwethu Makhanya looks the exact type of player who could go for big money because his versatility is what teams crave. The only reason the imposing South African might go under the radar is that many sides likely have their eyes firmly fixed on those performing above expectations in European competition.
Makhanya didn't get that chance with Rangers this season, but he appears to be a player destined for the sharp end of European football in the years to come. His brilliance against Celtic, effectively playing two positions in one game, will have attracted admiring glances.
David Irvine: Despite some wobbles, I still think Emmanuel Fernandez is the player most likely to attract a big-name suitor if there is tangible interest in January. The 25-year-old centre-back has all the physical attributes required to become a top defender, but his concentration can sometimes let him down.
There is little wonder he has previously been linked with the likes of Bayer Leverkusen, given his stature and speed, but he will only truly fulfil his potential if he combines his prime physical prowess with the mental attributes necessary to make it at the highest level.
There are some similarities with Calvin Bassey in the way he can be such an imposing force while still being prone to the occasional blip. As he matures into a vastly experienced centre-back, however, his potential could bring big money to the table.
Graeme Young: Frick seems like a motivator, but I gasped when I heard that the top six was on his agenda. I have deep concerns over the make-up of this Aberdeen squad and, while the new man has arrived with a parachute and a can-do attitude, there are plenty of teams in the Premiership who simply look better.
Frick needs this to go well quickly because his squad is bereft of belief. But all hope is far from lost. His record at Luzern gets better the more you dig into it. What I'm saying is, it's not you, Mario, it might be your new team.
David Irvine: I find Mario Frick a wholly fascinating character. He has the reputation of a manager capable of mounting a rescue mission, and that is what he is walking into at Aberdeen.
Like Graeme, I was a little concerned when the top six was mentioned so quickly because he has a job on his hands to steer the club clear of the bottom first and foremost. But I actually think Aberdeen have enough to make the top six. It might just mean the football is more heavy mettle than heavy metal.
Graeme Young: He may well do. However, I think his greatest selling point is his knack for making an impact from the bench.
Yang appears primed to make the left-hand side his own, with Jota providing competition as he works his way back to full fitness. That might allow Osmand to move back into the rotation as a second striker, a back-up No. 9 and the best option to provide a jolt from the bench on either wing.
David Irvine: There is certainly something in Callum Osmand’s ability to cause chaos when he comes off the bench. He has shown that in recent months.
Crucially, though, he must develop into a starter for Celtic. He has the necessary ability, but he must translate that into performances across 90 minutes.
Yang is likely the more natural starter and Jota will always carry himself as a key player for Celtic, but Osmand has an opportunity to nail down a starting spot. He just needs to take it.