According to a report by BBC Sport on Monday, October 19, 2026, Manchester United have come under renewed criticism for retaining Michael Carrick as manager, with Marco Silva viewed as a possible alternative who could have brought more stability and potentially saved the club the cost of another managerial change.

United’s poor start to the Premier League season has intensified questions about the club’s managerial decisions, particularly as Carrick struggles to produce consistent performances and results.

The Red Devils have reportedly secured only one win in their opening league matches, raising concerns about the decision to keep the former midfielder in charge. Their Champions League loss to Atletico Madrid has further increased the pressure ahead of their difficult away fixture against Leeds United.

Despite enjoying an impressive spell last season, Carrick’s recent struggles have revived debate about United’s preference for appointing former players in the hope of bringing back the club’s former success. The experiences of previous managers, including Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, have prompted questions about whether familiarity with Manchester United is enough to deliver positive results.

Silva was reportedly one of the managers the club could have targeted during the summer transfer window. The Portuguese coach departed Fulham after a promising spell in English football before taking over at Benfica, where he has reportedly made a strong start.

The 49-year-old has extensive experience in England, having managed Fulham, Everton, Watford and Hull City. His understanding of the Premier League could have made him a suitable candidate as United looked to improve their tactical approach and achieve greater consistency.

Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola has previously spoken highly of Silva’s coaching qualities, backing him to become one of football’s leading managers.

“Marco is one of the top, top, top managers I face. Destined to be one of the top in a few years for sure,” Guardiola said in February.

The report stated that Silva won 12 of his first 16 games at Benfica, recording only two defeats during that period. His early results have added weight to suggestions that United may have missed an opportunity by not considering him more seriously.

Brighton manager Fabian Hürzeler has also reportedly emerged as a potential candidate if Manchester United decide to part ways with Carrick.

However, dismissing the current manager could result in additional compensation and recruitment costs. Although Silva’s progress at Benfica has strengthened his reputation, there is no certainty he would have enjoyed the same success at Old Trafford, leaving United’s managerial decision open to debate.