SuperSport presenter Thomas Mlambo is facing renewed scrutiny following a fiery on-air exchange with former Bafana Bafana defender Matthew Booth, who publicly challenged what he described as a bias towards Orlando Pirates during a live broadcast of Extra Time TV. The confrontation, which circulated widely on social media on Tuesday, 13 October 2026, has reignited a long-standing debate about impartiality among South African football pundits and television analysts .

The flashpoint came after Mamelodi Sundowns claimed the MTN8 title on Saturday, 11 October 2026, defeating Orlando Pirates 2-0 at Moses Mabhida Stadium to collect their second trophy of the season . During the post-match discussion, when the conversation appeared to veer towards a particular season's PSL title, Booth pushed back firmly. "No, no, no, no," he repeated as the host continued, before cutting through with a direct reminder: "Last season's PSL title went to Orlando Pirates in case you didn't remember" .

The exchange quickly drew attention to how rival clubs are discussed during broadcasts on South African television. Booth's remarks formed part of a broader conversation about coverage standards and whether presenters maintain the neutrality expected of their roles, particularly when discussing clubs with large supporter bases like Orlando Pirates .

Viewers on X weighed in on the controversy, with one user framing Booth's criticism as a direct challenge to Mlambo and Phumudzo Manenzhe over perceived favouritism towards Orlando Pirates. The post distinguished former players, who may openly support a club, and working presenters, who are held to a different standard of impartiality. Another user questioned how broadcasters select on-air talent, suggesting that positions should be advertised openly so candidates can compete on merit .

This is not the first time Mlambo's commentary has sparked debate. In a separate incident, a social media user recalled his overly optimistic assessment of Bafana Bafana's AFCON group prospects, contrasting it with Booth's more measured approach of treating tournament qualification as a standard expectation rather than cause for excessive celebration . The recurring pattern has led some supporters to question whether SuperSport's editorial standards adequately ensure balance when covering South Africa's biggest clubs. Neither Mlambo nor SuperSport has issued a formal response to the latest criticism.

Source https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1DPiynUprq/