flag
back Back
Has Celtic damaged Nancy’s career … or was it always doomed to failure?

Did Celtic ruin a promising career? Or did we expose the hollow man at the centre of a myth?

2025 Scottish Premiership Football Motherwell v Celtic Dec 30th
30th December 2025; Fir Park, Motherwell, Scotland; Scottish Premiership Football, Motherwell versus Celtic; Celtic manager Wilfried Nancy

Wilfried Nancy is having a hard time. Look at the latest reports about him and you’ll see that clearly. He’s not had a job since he left Celtic Park. Is that a reflection on him, or did we do that to him? That’s a question worth answering, so let’s try to.

For a lot of people, the questions that will come to mind are why do we need to discuss this? Is this really something worth talking about when there are so many other things going on at Celtic? And the answer to those questions is definitely yes.

Because this does have profound implications for us. If Nancy’s reputation was destroyed at Celtic Park, then it doesn’t take any great depth of thinking to recognise why that might be a problem for the future.

If Nancy just isn’t all that impressive, if MLS, where he achieved his success, isn’t all that highly rated, then you’re talking about a different question entirely. And that has implications of its own. Just not for Celtic.

Maybe it is exactly what so many of his critics said it was: that MLS is just a poor-quality league. That it’s a place where top European players go for their retirements and their pension top-ups.

I like watching MLS football. It is exciting. It is fast. It is aggressive. And I think there’s a high degree of technical skill in that league.

But because of the nature of American sports, and because of the nature of a league like that, where expectations are generally lower outside the franchise clubs themselves, which are desperate to win things, it is not taken as seriously as other leagues around the world.

But then my exact criticism of the Ange appointment was that he had only proved himself in the Australian league, the Japanese league and, for a brief time, as an international boss. And that turned out to have hidden a manager of genuine talent and genuine gravitas.

The problem, as quickly becomes apparent when comparing the two, is that there was much more in Ange’s background you could point to than just success at a single club. Ange had won titles on two continents. He had won an international trophy as a national team boss. At Spurs, he went on to win the Europa League.

That’s an elite manager. And there was never any real sign, after he arrived here, that Nancy was one of them. Yes, his stylistic choices, his formation and his ideas were an absolute winner in MLS. His free-thinking departure from the norms is what made him a rising star, which is why we took him from that league.

But the question is, was that the wrong league in which to try to build a reputation in the first place? And that’s a much more complicated question than I have time to explore in full today. Save to say this; football may take a different view from many of our supporters, who believe Nancy was hopelessly out of his depth.

I never felt like he understood the size of the challenge or the scale of the expectations. I never believed he got it. When he sat in the aftermath of losing a League Cup final to St Mirren and dismissed it as if it was of no consequence, I knew then that he didn’t get where he was or what he was expected to do.

But it may just be that others in football view the circumstances under which he was thrown into the job at Celtic as a mitigating factor.

And you know what? That’s pretty damning for us if they do.

Because it means that, in many ways, we are the problem, not him. It means there was a board of directors that said it would back him and then got spooked by the avalanche of criticism. It means Celtic looks like a knee-jerk club where new ideas will never be allowed to flourish unless they prove to be instantaneously successful.

It means that we’re not just facing problems attracting a top-class manager, which we know we’re not going to be able to do under this present board, in no small part because of the Rodgers statement that appeared on the club website. It means we’re not going to get an opportunity to hire certain up-and-coming managers either.

Because any up-and-coming manager with radical ideas, who has not yet got a name and a reputation of substance to fall back on, as Rodgers did, is going to look at what happened to Nancy and see a possible career-making gig.

But it’s also potentially career-destroying as well.

And whilst there’s an argument for saying that this sorts out the serious people from the deeply unserious ones, those who have absolute faith and personal conviction in their ideas and who won’t be dissuaded by that possibility at all, I would tend to argue that anybody who looks at Wilfried Nancy lasting eight games would be wondering if Celtic is really that safe a bet.

So, I don’t like seeing him flounder after Celtic. I would love to see Nancy go somewhere and do well, and justify the reputation that he arrived at Celtic with. Because then perhaps the football world will conclude that he simply arrived here at a crazy time, when the odds were stacked against him.

Of course, those who look closely at the way Celtic behaved during that entire spell will still see deeply suspect behaviour from us.

The hiring itself was insanity if we weren’t going to give the guy time to bed in his ideas. And those ideas may themselves have been far too radical for us to have attempted without a major cushion to fall back on.

But don’t forget that the fan media, who could have been this guy’s vanguard, were excluded from the press conference to unveil him.

That gave us no chance to get to know him, no chance to listen to him personally outline his ideas, no chance to ask him the questions that may have given him the breathing space he needed in that early spell, just as Ange had the breathing space he needed to endure his own difficult start.

The fact that the press conference to unveil him was itself so low-key, almost as if there were people at the club who didn’t want to sit there beside him, who didn’t want to have to own the decision to hire him, sent the worst possible message straight away.

Did we know how dramatically he intended to change things?

I find it hard to believe that we did. I find it hard to believe that we either knew about it or understood the major impact that a radical change in tactics and style was going to have on a team which had just about stabilised under O’Neill and was going into some of the most consequential games of the season.

If they understood the scale of what he was trying to do and then threw him into that set of fixtures, well, that says everything about their judgement that we ever need to know. And so I don’t think that, if you look closely enough at this, there’s any mitigation for Celtic at all.

I have no idea whether Wilfried Nancy was, and is, a manager with top-class potential. I know that he did not understand Celtic. But that does not mean he cannot be a transformational manager somewhere else.

Perhaps his ideas are simply too dramatic for certain environments. Some people thought the same about Ange, and they worked.

Nancy’s next appointment will tell us a great deal about whether his success in MLS was the foundation of a genuinely impressive managerial career or whether Celtic exposed limitations that were always there. He might blow the competition away. He might blow himself out like a birthday candle. But whatever happens next, it cannot change the fact that Celtic made a monumental mess of his appointment.

We recruited a manager whose philosophy demanded time, patience and a willingness to endure difficult results. We handed him a squad that wasn’t built for his methods, threw him into a horrendous run of fixtures and then dismissed him after eight games.

I believe that dismissal was necessary. I could see that the story was not going to have a happy ending. But that does not absolve the people who hired him in the first place.

In spite of his dreadful interviews and dreadful results, I feel bad for the guy. He arrived at a club which didn’t quite believe in him, inherited a dressing room which didn’t believe in him at all, faced a hostile, sceptical media and encountered a fan base already at war with the club on any number of fronts.

And the consequences may extend far beyond Nancy himself.

If he succeeds elsewhere, Celtic will look like a club that took a talented manager, threw him in at the deep end and damaged his career through sheer incompetence. If he fails elsewhere, we’ll still have to explain why we appointed a manager so spectacularly unsuited to the circumstances he was walking into.

Neither outcome reflects well on us.

And any young, ambitious manager considering Celtic as a springboard to a great career will have to weigh the opportunity against what happened to Wilfried Nancy. That is the lasting damage here. Not simply the embarrassment of his eight games, but the possibility that we’ve made an already difficult managerial recruitment job even harder.

Either way, I think we made one heck of a mess.

Choose The CelticBlog as a Preferred Source on Google News

You may like

Celtic Star Pays Incredible Tribute to Auston Trusty

celtsarehere.com 23 hours ago

Arne Engels Makes Surprise Announcement After Celtic Exit

celtsarehere.com 11 hours ago

A token fan on the board won’t fix what is broken at Celtic.

thecelticblog.com 1 day ago

I'm a Real Madrid icon who won five Champions Leagues and the World Cup but playing at Celtic Par...

Daily Record 4 hours ago

Celtic looking to ‘get ahead of competition’ and seal signing – O’Neill’s side send official

sportwitness.co.uk 2 days ago

Celtic needs to show Clearie the pathway before English clubs come knocking.

thecelticblog.com 2 days ago