flag
back Back
Why Andy Halliday’s Minsu Kim swipe crosses a line on Derek McInnes at Rangers
Rangers manager Derek McInnes, Sky Sports pundit Andy Halliday
Credit: Ian MacNicol/Getty Images

Findlay Curtis deserves full credit for the spark he keeps bringing off the bench for Rangers – yet Andy Halliday’s post-match swipe at Minsu Kim after Saturday’s dramatic 2-1 Scottish Premiership victory at Motherwell missed the mark and unfairly questioned Derek McInnes’ winning formula.

Speaking on Sky Sports following Ryan Naderi’s deflected 88th-minute winner at Fir Park, Halliday argued that the 20-year-old academy graduate, who has featured in every match this season bar being an unused substitute against St Johnstone on 24 October, has earned a run of starts after repeatedly influencing games as a substitute.

On that front, Halliday has a point. Curtis came on for Minsu in the 78th minute at Fir Park and injected fresh urgency into Rangers‘ attack as they chased down a late winner. There is a growing case for him to earn a starting berth sooner rather than later.

Where Halliday’s analysis unravelled, however, was in his framing of £8.5million summer signing Minsu, and what that insinuated about McInnes’ management.

I don’t think that Findlay Curtis would get away with playing 12 games, 12 starts, and getting zero goals and zero assists. I just don’t. And that’s not being critical of [Badredine] Bouanani and Minsu Kim, because I think both of them are really promising players, but for me personally, I think Minsu Kim has been poor three games in a row now. So if that’s the case, I think that’s when you bring him out and give Findlay Curtis a run.

TalkingPoints

BIG win late on for Rangers as they keep the pressure on Celtic! What did you make of that? 🤩

They are now four points off the top with a game in hand!

Halliday’s claim immediately clashed with what happened in Motherwell vs Rangers

The most glaring flaw in Halliday’s argument is what actually transpired on the pitch in Lanarkshire, and what the underlying numbers show.

Making his 13th appearance and 12th start for Rangers since arriving from Girona in an £8.5m summer switch, Minsu literally registered his first assist of the season on Saturday night, whipping in the corner that Emmanuel Fernandez converted to hand Rangers an eighth-minute lead.

Even before that assist, Minsu has hardly been a passenger in the final third. He currently leads Rangers for both big chances created (5, ahead of Naderi and Curtis on 4) and total chances created (26, ahead of Djeidi Gassama on 25 and Naderi on 17).

Far from contributing nothing across 12 starts, the South Korean winger has consistently opened up defences and directly unlocked Motherwell’s backline early on before Jake Girdwood-Reich levelled for the hosts in the 21st minute.

McInnes’ winning formula deserves trust, not second-guessing

More importantly, suggesting that Minsu is somehow getting away with starting matches without contributing paints McInnes as a manager blindly indulging an underperforming player.

Nothing could be further from the truth. Saturday’s triumph at Fir Park extended Rangers’ unbeaten run to 13 matches, including 11 victories, keeping the pressure firmly on league leaders Celtic.

McInnes is managing a young, £8.5m signing adapting to Scottish football while maintaining a finely balanced matchday blueprint: trusting Minsu’s creation and set-piece delivery from the outset, before unleashing Curtis’ direct energy against tired legs in the closing stages.

It is worth noting that Halliday himself has been previously complimentary of Minsu.

All stats courtesy of FotMob

You may like

Rangers 'in talks' with several clubs over permanent exit for star

glasgowtimes.co.uk 1 day ago

Rangers fans treated awfully as new image emerges from Fir Park ahead of Motherwell clash

rangersnews.uk 19 hours ago

And so it came to pass with Bruno Guimaraes… Newcastle United 2 Arsenal 2

themag.co.uk 3 hours ago

Rangers player ratings vs Motherwell: 4/10 trio let McInnes down as Fernandez stars

rangersnews.uk 16 hours ago

Armstrong on Rangers transfer links and McInnes admiration

www-tmp.thenational.scot 1 day ago

Celtic penalty outrage exposes Derek McInnes double standards – where’s the anger now?

vitalfootball.co.uk 2 days ago

Lamine Yamal strikes post from spot with Barcelona 2-0 down

besoccer.com 43 minutes ago

Rangers may explore Jens Hjerto-Dahl loan in January amid struggles at Hull City

rangersnews.uk 1 day ago

The forgotten Rangers player who 'might be option' for loan recall

www-tmp.thenational.scot 2 days ago

Fresh John Souttar blow makes Rangers blunder look more foolish than ever

rangersnews.uk 2 hours ago